Stay with Fios or go back to DTV?

[dishrich]

Moxi only works with cable correct? Not sat systems?

Correct - it also does NOT work with any OTA signals.
Also, if your cable system is NOT all digital, (if you have analog channels NOT duplicated digitally) then you'll have to order their analog tuner module.



The HD Tivo does not have either of these issues...

[lern4483]

Correct - it also does NOT work with any OTA signals.
Also, if your cable system is NOT all digital, (if you have analog channels NOT duplicated digitally) then you'll have to order their analog tuner module.

The HD Tivo does not have either of these issues...

Moxi will not work with Telco as well? Uverse/Fios?

Thanks again. Looks like a great machine...

[dishrich]

Moxi will not work with Telco as well? Uverse/Fios?

WILL w/FiOS (see previous replies), NOT w/U-verse - they use different technologies

[riffjim4069]

OK ,Just to clairify, You seem to recommend using Tivo Boxes with Fios Service? Correct?
If I had the option to go with Fios, Which many including myself ,don't have the option at all to do so. What would 3 Tivo HD DVRs cost me upfront ,and what would the addtional monthly fee's cost me?

I currently have 2 Vip 622 and 1 722k. I want to keep the same setup 3 rooms HD DVR and 2 SD DVR. The 722 is only used in 1 room in single mode.

Last Time I checked Tivo 100 hour HD DVR cost $600.
Thats $1800 for 3 room of HD DVR.
Worst case for a 5 room setup with D* 3 HD DVD 2-SD DVR would cost you $800. Thats if No discounts are givin.

My E* Setup at worst would cost $750 for 2 leased and 1 owned HD DVR.

So my Question . Is paying $1000 extra in DVR's Just to have a decent DVR selection worth the difference in HD PQ. I say no! Fios is about $50 better the D* and $75 better then E* in HD PQ.
Yes you'll own these Tivos, But they will never work with any Satellite company, and only some cable companys ever give you the Tivo option.
So if I have to pay for Verizon Fios, Then pay Tivo $600 to buy a GOOD HD DVR, Whats Verizon going to give me for not using their crappy HD DVR?
Not starting a fight with you, But why would using Tivos make any sence,over using D* equipment,Service,and HD PQ.?
I think a Channel line up and slightly better HD PQ, isn't enough to settle for poor equipment, and to put it nicely, Unpredictable,technical and customer service department.

I don't have much time so here are the bullets:

- FiOS TV has 117 national HD channels, E* has 87 if you include HD-Lite...zero if you do not include HD-Lite. Some people don't mind HD-Lite, but the numbers speak for themselves.
Official AVS National HD Channel Lineups - Cable/DBS/Fiber/IPTV - Updated 10/26/09! - AVS Forum

-FiOS TV offers 10 HD locals...more than double E*.
- I paid $200 for my brand new TivoHD and $79 for a 500GB hard-drive ($279 for a 660GB HD DVR). Not sure why you would pay $600 for a TivoHD?
- Since you're comparing full price then I have three 622s sitting in my closet that cost over $1500. Needless to say, they are not being used.
- FiOS TV Extreme HD, 20/5 internet and phone cost $173 per month (and that inlcluded a bunch of movie channels, a Verizon HD DVR, and two cable cards for a Tivo and Sony HD DVR, and two free SD adapters). We were paying about $120 for similar E* programming (minus all the HD) with two DVRs.
- You failed to mention multiple received and DVR fees with E*.
- My FiOS (all three services) have experienced not one second of downtime in the past 21-months.
- V* has 30-117 more HD national channels (depending on your appetite for HD-Lite)
- V* has 6 more local HD channels
- V* is a much better bundled value
- V* and TivoHD is an excellent/competitive product (almost as good as the VIP DVR)
- Overall, V* costs much less than E* when you bundle TV and Internet.
- Again, there is no reason to pay more than $300 for a new Tivo.

However, if you're happy with E*'s overpriced HD-Lite then by all means stay the course...the VIP DVR is outstanding!

[vurbano]

Ditto...stay with FiOS TV and get yourself a TivoHD. There are a number of us former D* and E* customers who have FiOS and TivoHD (in the Verizon FiOS Forum) and we are extremely satisfied with the service.

ditto. If I still had D* Id be without service the last 48 hours.

[Hemi 6.1]

I don't have much time so here are the bullets:


-FiOS TV offers 10 HD locals...more than double E*.
- I paid $200 for my brand new TivoHD and $79 for a 500GB hard-drive ($279 for a 660GB HD DVR). Not sure why you would pay $600 for a TivoHD?
!

Well $599 right from Tivo site.

http://www.tivo.com/dvr-products/tiv...dvr/index.html

Or $299 for a 20 Hour DVR.

https://www3.tivo.com/dvr-products/t...dvr/index.html

And Show us all a link for a $200 HD DVR Tivo that has more then 20 hours recording.
And Here is the fine print.

https://www3.tivo.com/abouttivo/poli...ndowpopup.html

So Sugar coat it all you want, But facts are above, and Fios with Tivo ,don't make it at all a bargon.
Oh and lets not forget your External Hard drive from Tivo.

https://www3.tivo.com/dvr-products/t...ex.html#A00096

[Hemi 6.1]

- You failed to mention multiple received and DVR fees with E*.
- My FiOS (all three services) have experienced not one second of downtime in the past 21-months.

3 722's with Everything pack are $14 per month in fee's. So you failed to mention Tivos $13 per month fee , Just to use a Tivo.
Got anything else?
With E* AEP its $102.99
+ $10 HD including platinum
and $14 for 3 722K,s
Thats a Total of $126.99

[riffjim4069]

So Sugar coat it all you want, But facts are above.

No need to sugar coat the sweet HD picture (SD too!), sweet reliability, and sweet savings of having FiOS. As far as paying full-retail...I can't recall anyone in the FiOS TV forum paying anywhere close to full-retail for their TivoHD setup. Additionally, although it is hard to put a price tag on quality, let's just say the best service (check the JDPower survey and others if you wish) is also the better value.

Oh and lets not forget your External Hard drive from Tivo.

https://www3.tivo.com/dvr-products/t...ex.html#A00096

Again, if you wish to pay full-retail...so be it. The DVR Expander is sold in dozens of discount electronic stores. For example, the 1TB WD My DVR Expander is sold on Tivo.com for $199.99 (as you mentioned), however you failed to mention that it also sells for $129.00 w/free shipping on Amazon.com - hmmm...if I combine the $219.00 TiVO HD w/free shipping I found online with the $129.00 1TB eSATA drive, that gives me a 1.16TB TivoHD for $348.00 vice the 1TB Tivo XL you would buy at Tivo for $599.99

Anyway, I just noticed the price of the MoxiHD was reduced to $499. The unit comes with lifetime service which makes it cheaper to own than a TivoHD, and competitively priced with the 722 since there are no monthly DVR and additional receiver fees.

In my opinion, FiOS is a superior service and a better overall value...although it's probably more expensive to purchase multiple Tivos whilte not bundling services. The FiOS DVR is lackluster, but the TivoHD picks up the slack. As I mentioned many times before...we enjoyed E* service (provided a good value) and loved their VIP DVRs.. However, their HD-Lite is an absolute eye-sore and I just couldn't watch it any longer. I would gladly considering signing-up with E* (still have three 622s) just as long as they improve their picture quality.

and Fios with Tivo ,don't make it at all a bargon

Again, it's hard to place a value on quality...but I would feel gypped knowing that I paid my hard-earned money for TurboHD only to discover there is nothing HD about it. FiOS TV provides 117 National HD channels and 10 HD locals. What a bargain!

[riffjim4069]

3 722's with Everything pack are $14 per month in fee's. So you failed to mention Tivos $13 per month fee , Just to use a Tivo.
Got anything else?
With E* AEP its $102.99
+ $10 HD including platinum
and $14 for 3 722K,s
Thats a Total of $126.99

I don't like the Tivo fees...that's why I only have one. Plus, it costs me nothing to use my 2006 model 500GB Sony HD DVR with FiOS. Additionally, you are not considering the bundled the savings I mentioned. Being a former E* AEP subscriber, I have a strong feeling a comparable E* programming package, broadband Internet service, and phone would be considerably more than the FiOS Triple Play.

Let's see if I have this straight...you're paying $136.99 for your 87 TurboHD-Lite channels with 722s while I am paying $173.00 for 117 pristine ExtremeHD channels (1 FiOS HD DVR, 1 TivoHD, 1 Sony HD DVR)?

...oh, I almost forgot the additional $45 ($10 for Tivo service) also covers our 20/5 Internet service and unlimited phone service.

Also, don't forget the EchoStar "tru2way" T2200S is currently being beta tested by some cable companies. It would be schweet if FiOS were to license a non-tru2way model.

The $499 MoxiHD is expandable to 6.5TB on eSATA storage (not that cheesy and slow USB).

Finally, I can understand your confusion since you never actually had FiOS service.

[madmadworld]

.127 unmodified national HD channels

how many gigs per hour when you record a 720 and a 1080 program ?
thanks alot