Although I've been a DirecTV customer for many years, I'm new to DVRs, just recently got into an HR20. My second TV, which is non-HD, and won't be upgraded any time in the near future, I'm running one of my former hand me down DirecTV units. But I've been given a Samsung/Tivo SIR S4040R, and wondered whether it's still considered a good unit.

By that I mean, is this something that is still viable with DirecTV? I know that D is moving toward their own DVR technology, moving away from Tivo units. I can't seem to find any recent references to this unit through the search options, so I'm guessing it's possibly more than a couple of years old.

Outside of it's non-HD capability (which for the second TV, I don't need), and it's small hard drive (40GB), is there any reason not to pursue activating this with DirecTV?

Thanks, Jim

i say go ahead activate it, another dvr never hurts, if the small hdd bothers you check out ptvupgrade.com
your hdd can easily be upgraded so you coul dhave lots more record time with your tivo
this is for dtv tivo's only not the hr20

__________________
Target Field Season Ticket Holder Excel Center Season Ticket Holder Tcf Bank Season Ticket Holder Target Center Season Ticket Holder
TwiningAgain WildingAgain GopherNation WolvingAgain
*ISH Apr 22 04-? AEPhd,ss,Euron rsn pack on VIP622, VIP722k, and VIP922AUDIT TEAM IS WORTHLESS!DITCH DISH Cable 6416 Apr.06 *tv 4 hr20 HdDvr(Software 0x3A8 CutEdgeTester)*vu 6000c,2 9242,2 5900*C dsr 530 HdDvr dsr505 3 HDA2's Iphone 3GS 4.0 software jailbroken and unlocked Google Nexus One rooted frf85b sofware version 2.2 Ps3,PsP,Wii 4.2u with homebrew channel and usb loader gx,3 360 1 20gb hdd 2 250gb hdd(1HdDVD),xbox
Im Purple DtvPal Dvr with 1tb hdd Sam DTBH260F
Ps3 500gb hdd Folding Home StonePhillips420

I have a samsung s4080r and its a great unit. It runs flawlessly.

__________________
Tom
Directv since 1995, Samsung DTIVO retired , MRV, HR22-100, HR24-500 ,R16
Vizio VL370M, Harmony 520, Sony Blu-Ray, Wii, Xbox 360

Gee, I'm real sorry your mom blew up, Ricky....Better off dead

Unfortunately I'm on the road a lot, but I tried to get this unit activated this past weekend. What should have been a 5 minute call to DirecTV CSR turned into a 30 minute call because the CSR apparently had little experience with activating a unit!

After all was done, I didn't have any locals. He put me on hold, and came back to say that I needed a new card to activate the unit. Why didn't he tell me that up front.? I was just PO'd at the whole experience, and told him to reactivate my other unit instead. Since this was for a secondary TV, and I didn't really need the DVR aspect, I will probably just stay with what I have.