Thread: Ceteris Paribus why would anyone get Dish if D* has more channels

and more exclusive channels, MLB NFL ST etc, just asking.

Is it because the Dish CEO has TV chats? Or because a lot of thieves feel guilty and subscribe to dish

Some people prefer the DVRs that Dish has, there is a HD only package that D* doesnt offer. Lower prices if you can get the package just right (although this can go both ways), a few channels that D* doesnt have (vice versa), and a good many premiums that D* doesnt offer.

I sometimes wonder about the same thing, why do people stick to Comcast when they charge $17 per DVR, and carry only about half of the HD channels compared to E* and D*?

There must be a lot of "stupid people" out there, and if a company can make a lot of money off so many "stupid people", why bother trying anything else?

In my case it's simply a matter of cost and features.

TurboHD Gold $39.99 (all the HD channels I normally watch; I don't want to watch anything in SD)
Locals $5
DVR Fee $5.98
NHL Center Ice $159/season (Same price for D* and E*, slight edge to D* on HD coverage with MSG-HD)
Cinemax annual sub with auto-pay $0.01/year

With the 722 I can record 3 things at once (1 OTA tuner + 2 SAT tuners), and the overall usability of E*'s hardware is quite good.

I've poked around D*'s site looking at packages because of all of the coverage in the forums here, but I can't find a package that comes close for features & price for the channels I watch.

Originally Posted by espaeth

In my case it's simply a matter of cost and features.

TurboHD Gold $39.99 (all the HD channels I normally watch; I don't want to watch anything in SD)
Locals $5
DVR Fee $5.98
NHL Center Ice $159/season (Same price for D* and E*, slight edge to D* on HD coverage with MSG-HD)
Cinemax annual sub with auto-pay $0.01/year

With the 722 I can record 3 things at once (1 OTA tuner + 2 SAT tuners), and the overall usability of E*'s hardware is quite good.

I've poked around D*'s site looking at packages because of all of the coverage in the forums here, but I can't find a package that comes close for features & price for the channels I watch.

Unfortunately this is about the only arrangement that E* still has a good advantage over all other providers. I am hoping when Feb comes around they will in fact add all the new HDs they say they will add for 09, that will make their TurboHD packs real standalone alternatives, even with the price increase.

For you however already have the TurboHD Gold, a $10 price increase will be significant.

But once you go beyond the first HD DVR, E*'s fees start to add up fast. And once you go beyond 4 to 6 tuners, it becomes almost a no go.

Originally Posted by jacmyoung

I sometimes wonder about the same thing, why do people stick to Comcast when they charge $17 per DVR, and carry only about half of the HD channels compared to E* and D*?

There must be a lot of "stupid people" out there, and if a company can make a lot of money off so many "stupid people", why bother trying anything else?

In my case it isw a rental house and the neighbor has big trees to my south. No view of sat.

I agree on cost, but my Comcast is comparable to DISH on HD, although a different mix (I get AMC and SPEED-HD). I also get a lot of VoD, including HD and it is true On Demand, not the weird pre-download stuff.