I'm confused about why I would want a DirecTV DVR over a Tivo. Frankly I've been a ReplayTV user for several years now and love it! Sadly ReplayTV has gone the way of the dinosaurs. Now that I just got a new HD TV, I'd like to upgrade to DirecTV's HD service and am wondering what is the better route. I recognize that the streamlined approach would be to go with the DirecTV DVR, but couldn't I purchase an HD Tivo and a DirecTV HD Receiver and accomplish the same thing? What is the big advantage in going with the first option other than the obvious: less equipment to deal with?
Thanks in advance for any help you can give.