Top three QB's in the history of each NFL franchise

[Jimbo]

If Colin Kaepernick keeps it up,he'll replace John Brodie as my 3rd all-time QB for the 49ers & might even challenge Steve Young for the number 2 spot.

1 year of experience doesn't make it to the top three in my book.
Gotta have some longevity, show that you didn't do it in 1 year and nothing after it.

 

[Scherrman]

I agree. I think you have to be with a team at least 4-5 years and put up consistent stats.

 

[Neutron]

We should have a thread for the top 3 worst QBs for each team.

 

[madmadworld]

We should have a thread for the top 3 worst QBs for each team.

as a Browns fan need many more than 3 for the new Browns.

 

[Hart5150]

We should have a thread for the top 3 worst QBs for each team.

Patriots

1.Hugh Millen
2.Tommy Hodson
3.Tony Eason

I could name plenty more

Marc Wilson
Scott Secules
Matt Cavanaugh

 

[BillD1984]

Patriots

1.Hugh Millen
2.Tommy Hodson
3.Tony Eason

I could name plenty more

Marc Wilson
Scott Secules
Matt Cavanaugh

Mine would be:

1 (worst) Marc Wilson
2. Scott Secules
3. Scott Zolak

 

[Scherrman]

Do the worst QBs need to have played a certain amount of games to be qualified? The Bears have gone through so many QBs in the past it's hard to choose.

 

[BillD1984]

Do the worst QBs need to have played a certain amount of games to be qualified? The Bears have gone through so many QBs in the past it's hard to choose.

It can anybody you think qualifies. My criteria would be they had to have been the #1 QB for at least half the season, but that's me.

 

[Bodo Fenrirsson]

If Colin Kaepernick keeps it up,he'll replace John Brodie as my 3rd all-time QB for the 49ers & might even challenge Steve Young for the number 2 spot.

1 year of experience doesn't make it to the top three in my book.
Gotta have some longevity, show that you didn't do it in 1 year and nothing after it.

I agree. I think you have to be with a team at least 4-5 years and put up consistent stats.

That's why I added the caveat "IF." IF Colin CONTINUES to play the rest of his career like he did yesterday,THEN he'll bump John Brodie from my list & maybe even nudge Steve Young from number 2. People tried to make it sound like all that Colin could do was run,& if you contain the read offense then you contain him. Like Russell Wilson,Colin Kaepernick was a baseball prospect,which to me means that he has an arm to throw the ball(although,yes,I do know that there is a big difference between throwing a football & a baseball). I was impressed with Colin yesterday & I do hope that he keeps it up AND that he has a long & successful career.

 

[SabresRule]

Buffalo Bills

1. Jim Kelly

2. Joe Ferguson

3. Doug Flutie

 

[Bodo Fenrirsson]

Buffalo Bills

1. Jim Kelly

2. Joe Ferguson

3. Doug Flutie

Buffalo Bills

1. Jim Kelly

2. Jack Kemp

3. Joe Ferguson

I guess that you are too young to remember Jack Kemp before he became a politician & was QB for the old AFL Bills(before OJ).

 

[rabbitt83]

Detroit Lions

1. Bobby Layne

2. Dutch Clark

3. Greg Landry

1- Bobby Layne
2-Earl Morrow
3-Greg -Landry
That is the right order

 

[Peter Parker]

Arizona/St. Louis Cardinals

1. Jim Hart(St. Louis Cardinals)

2. Kurt Warner(Arizona Cardinals)

3. Charley Johnson(St. Louis Cardinals)

I guess the Chicago years are not even worth mentioning.

 

[Peter Parker]

Pittsburgh Steelers

1. Terry Bradshaw

2. Big Ben

3. Nobody else was good enough for this list.

Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2

MAybe you could gi ve Unitas an honorable mention.

 

[HipKat]

1- Bobby Layne
2-Earl Morrow
3-Greg -Landry
That is the right order

Wow, 8 yr old thread!

I'll play

royrdsjr said:
Buffalo Bills

1. Jim Kelly

2. Jack Kemp

3. Joe Ferguson

Jim Kelly
Jack Kemp
Josh Allen - who has equaled and broken many of Kelly's records

Fergy had heart, but his skill level was not as good as people want to remember

 

[Jimbo]

Wholey Moley, it's ALIVE, an 8 year old thread ...

Sorry Hipcat, didn't see your post till I replied.

 

[Derwin0]

Atlanta Falcons (not much to choose from):

1 - Matt Ryan
2 - Michael Vick
3 - Steve Bartkowski

 

[BillD1984]

It’s crazy but Tom Brady is probably already #1 on the Buccaneers list after only a year and a half, and they’ve been around since 1976.

 

[rabbitt83]

1- Bobby Layne
2-Earl Morrow
3-Greg -Landry
That is the right order

1-Bobby Layne
2-Earl Morrow
3-greg landry/Milt Plum

 

[Yespage]

It’s crazy but Tom Brady is probably already #1 on the Buccaneers list after only a year and a half, and they’ve been around since 1976.

Yeah, probably accurate, though Doug Williams is probably worth considering.

Tampa Bay, the team that had Steve Young and replaced him with Testaverde?!