I don't see channel 23 on that list. Anyway; your distance from the cluster of towers to the East would indicate that a four-bay bowtie (Antennas Direct dB4, Channel Master 4221) would work well. However, you're in Kentucky, so I looked a little harder, and you don't have a single channel within Line of Sight; they're all 2Edge at best, which means there's some potential for noise. I also noticed that there are only two VHF stations in less than 100 miles, so a UHF-only antenna is definitely the way to go. That puts me on the side of something with a finer beam width, like an
Antennas Direct 42XG. You may also get lucky using something like a
Winegard HD7696P to improve your FM reception while you're at it (no guarantees, that's not what it's made for), but it has nearly a 10' boom. You'll need at least 20' of elevation off the ground, and this all assumes that there isn't a giant cliff directly between you and the towers. Don't mess around with a rotator; you can't use one. Don't mess around with Radio Shack antenna amplfiers; if you need one, get a Channel Master, a Winegard, or a Motorola.