The shocking thing is that SciFi's ratings have never been higher. W13 is pulling in 50% more viewers than BSG did (and my 10 year old loves the show). I've two years of Sanctuary DVR'd along with last years 24 and LOST (yeah, I'm that far behind).
I'm still hanging with SGU, but the whole Stargate/BSG mashup is underwhelming. More heroism, miracle rescues, etc., and less brooding "we're ALL GONNA DIE!!!!" episodes.
Oh, and lose the stones. They make no sense and feel like a way to do a show on the cheap. Things grind to a halt whenever they go home. Use it for messages (a la Dwight Schultz on Voyager) and that's it.....
Oh, and I actually LIKE Eli. Am I the only one?