Can Dish Stop the Bleeding? Is Dish Bleeding?

Then he would have to watch the same programming on all three TV's.

With the 622 he can watch 1 program on his HD TV, and split the TV 2 to 2 set.

So nope, he's beeter off with Dish. It's saving him money.
 
I go by the hardware so i will stick with DISH. D* had crap for a long time and E* had an advantage. Most of the channels they have I would never watch
CW and FOXHD i do want but scifi types and others i never watch anyways.
 
While I agree the ext HD is a great feature, your statement isn't fair, if you never watch more than one TV at a time, you only need ONE receiver from DirecTV and send the same signals to the other two just like with 622.
I didn't know direct receivers had agile modulated output.