I agree, if he just said cable, I would consider it as a possibility. Cable varies so much from region to region. Even then, I would doubt that it blows the doors off of either. But putting dish up above at this point makes me wonder the set up and conditions. Something seems off somewhere (not saying it is the poster)Sorry, dont believe it its D's fault and never will.
Something is defective. Im not saying you are a liar, but I just dont think we know the whole story. Ive yet to see ONE person claim Cable looks better than D*. The fact your claiming Dish looks better, which hasnt in awhile, makes me wonder.