I did the "trash bag fix" before the 1st significant snow we had (covering the dish ONLY) and initially thought it worked well. No longer think so. It all depends on the conditions but after almost breaking my neck to clear just a small amount of snow/ice that collected on the bag it is now GONE--the bag, not the neck.......
Both times it was really only a small amount of snow/ice that caused me to lose signal. I've had WAY more snow collect on the bare dish in the past that barely decreased signal strength. The black garbage bag itself caused no reduction in signal but when snow/ice froze to the dish it was good-bye signal. Again, it was actually a small amount and my 1000.4 IS peaked and normally has excellent signal strength. I've purchased a small, 4"X5" stick-on 150 watt heating pad made for engine blocks but this old fart ain't gonna be installing it until the roof is snow free (Spring?LOL).
This was just my experience, others may vary...............
Ed