NFL Sunday Ticket Restrictions Legal?

dare2be

SatelliteGuys God
Lifetime Supporter
Jul 15, 2011
12,742
7,776
FL
I think any provider would be stupid not to pay the fee, since the fee is subscriber based anyway, and it would draw in more potential customers. And the NFL is stupid to not offer a tiered package offering (by team, division, conference, etc.) ...they would probably more than triple their subscriber base.
 

chicagonettech

SatelliteGuys Pro
Anti-trust is a synonym for monopoly . . . therefore no trust, no monopoly.

Go back and read the filing in its entirety.

The NFL was given an ANTI-TRUST WAIVER to make certain no one stepped on the fledgling, and then powerless, group of teams who initially formed the NFL, which gave them the loophole to negotiate the Sunday Night exclusive to games.

The legal people at IU are not claiming that the NFL is in violation of the Sherman Anti-Trust Act, only stating they want the WAIVER removed.

Once the waiver is removed, they automatically loose the exclusivity for the Sunday night games and the field becomes level again.

While there may, or may not, be anything to do with violation of the Sherman Anti-Trust Act, there WAS a VALID WAVER granted to the NFL to protect them when they were a small entity. They are no longer small and, therefore, do not require the protection of a waiver.

No waiver, no exclusions based on the waiver and the walls come tumbling down.
 

The Fat Man

aka. Dr. Fat Man
Lifetime Supporter
Oct 2, 2010
10,168
8,396
Land where we pronounce our "R" as "ah"
AND THERE IS STILL OTHER OPTIONS! Anti-Trust has to with saying that they are monopolizing a service. The NFL has provided alternatives. I'm not speaking of that particular law. The question is to whether it is legal. My answer is yes it is legal, and this is why!
 

dare2be

SatelliteGuys God
Lifetime Supporter
Jul 15, 2011
12,742
7,776
FL
Quite frankly look at all the issues in America, we're focused on legally trying to force the NFL to put Sunday Ticket on cable and Dish Network.
Honestly, of all the issues in America, this one seems to be solvable. ;)
 

Mr Tony

SatelliteGuys Pro
Supporting Founder
Nov 17, 2003
2,099
8,526
Mankato, MN
this is also being discussed in the D* area....I love this part

Furthermore, DirecTV is not a high-quality product. Besides
DirecTV’s well-known inability to transmit signals during bad weather,
the company has also recently received a “D+” grade from the Better
Business Bureau. A large portion of DirecTV users subscribe merely
because they are the only provider of Sunday Ticket; this disincentivizes
DirecTV from making any adjustments to its quality since it knows it will
always have a guaranteed subscriber base. By making Sunday Ticket
available to all carriers, each carrier would have to raise its quality of
product and service since each Sunday Ticket consumer would have a
greater choice, as opposed to being forced to cope with DirecTV’s
deficiencies.

moron has no clue how DBS works :)
 

Tampa8

Supporting Founder - I'll stand up and say so
Pub Member / Supporter
Lifetime Supporter
Sep 8, 2003
18,259
8,049
Tampa/Eastern Ct
this is also being discussed in the D* area....I love this part

Furthermore, DirecTV is not a high-quality product. Besides
DirecTV’s well-known inability to transmit signals during bad weather,
the company has also recently received a “D+” grade from the Better
Business Bureau. A large portion of DirecTV users subscribe merely
because they are the only provider of Sunday Ticket; this disincentivizes
DirecTV from making any adjustments to its quality since it knows it will
always have a guaranteed subscriber base. By making Sunday Ticket
available to all carriers, each carrier would have to raise its quality of
product and service since each Sunday Ticket consumer would have a
greater choice, as opposed to being forced to cope with DirecTV’s
deficiencies.

moron has no clue how DBS works :)

Lmao. Better than most any Cable company, hands down.
 

Tampa8

Supporting Founder - I'll stand up and say so
Pub Member / Supporter
Lifetime Supporter
Sep 8, 2003
18,259
8,049
Tampa/Eastern Ct
The fact that the most watched sports in America is generally still available on free TV (local team) is everything I need to know. NFL wants to put all their eggs in one basket for a paid package, I have no quarrel. MLB for the most part requires you to have Sat or Cable. Ditto Basketball, and the NHL. Let the NFL run the NFL, because the Government certainly can't.
 

ProfStata

SatelliteGuys Pro
Sep 11, 2003
248
7
West
dare2be said:
I didn't know you were a law professor...

The author got several facts wrong, including the availability of the NFL Network. He also didn't refer to other leagues' out-of-market packages. DirecTV used to have a monopoly on several of them and competition didnt't lower the price.
 

navychop

Member of the Month - July 2014!
Pub Member / Supporter
Lifetime Supporter
Jul 20, 2005
60,049
27,355
Northern VA
this is also being discussed in the D* area....I love this part

Furthermore, DirecTV is not a high-quality product. Besides
DirecTV’s well-known inability to transmit signals during bad weather,
the company has also recently received a “D+” grade from the Better
Business Bureau. A large portion of DirecTV users subscribe merely
because they are the only provider of Sunday Ticket; this disincentivizes
DirecTV from making any adjustments to its quality since it knows it will
always have a guaranteed subscriber base. By making Sunday Ticket
available to all carriers, each carrier would have to raise its quality of
product and service since each Sunday Ticket consumer would have a
greater choice, as opposed to being forced to cope with DirecTV’s
deficiencies.

moron has no clue how DBS works :)

Wow. Think this guy is capable of shame or embarrassment?
 

The Fat Man

aka. Dr. Fat Man
Lifetime Supporter
Oct 2, 2010
10,168
8,396
Land where we pronounce our "R" as "ah"
Iceberg said:
this is also being discussed in the D* area....I love this part

Furthermore, DirecTV is not a high-quality product. Besides
DirecTV’s well-known inability to transmit signals during bad weather,
the company has also recently received a “D+” grade from the Better
Business Bureau. A large portion of DirecTV users subscribe merely
because they are the only provider of Sunday Ticket; this disincentivizes
DirecTV from making any adjustments to its quality since it knows it will
always have a guaranteed subscriber base. By making Sunday Ticket
available to all carriers, each carrier would have to raise its quality of
product and service since each Sunday Ticket consumer would have a
greater choice, as opposed to being forced to cope with DirecTV’s
deficiencies.

moron has no clue how DBS works :)

Hey ice, I think this guy got all his sources from the cable commercials that attack satellite.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 0, Members: 0, Guests: 0)

Who Read This Thread (Total Members: 1)

Latest posts