With it being fully integrated I don't see why EHD support would be needed at all. Just get a larger EHD on the Hopper if more space is needed.
Correct, I could do that easily enough and it isn't like I don't have way too many EHDs floating around the house to use. I just thought it would be nice to have a 2nd one but connected to the SJ.
The SJ is in my 'tech room', connected to a Sony PS3 3D 24" display that is also used as my main monitor for my Apple MacBook Pro. Frankly I doubt that I'll use it much directly as I don't tend to watch TV except on my big screen 73". It would be neat if I could figger a way to have a split screen with the computer and SJ showing in some sort of PIP setup, but if there is a way I've not figured it out yet. That will be a winter project.
The SJ was gotten with the goal in mind of having 5 discrete tuners (8 during PrimeTime) and it does that just fine. I watch a lot of golf and boxing and it isn't uncommon to have contentions show up the 3 tuners, even with PTAT, didn't serve well enough. Hell, I've even got one day showing on the Dish system where there is a contention. Of course, that is handled pretty well with the reschedule for a later showing.
I'll split the package and programming level a bit between D* and E* to take advantage of the HD differences between them. I'll have HBO/Max on E* and Showtime on D*. And then whatever base package strikes my fancy. Most likely after the end of the year take D* down to as minimum as they'll allow w/Showtime, or possibly and more probably pay the ETF and cancel D*. All subject to change of course!!
HD picture quality these days between D* and E* is so very slight that it isn't a concern at all. I used to be able to tell that D* was slightly better, but now I can't tell any difference at all with the exception that the E* HD seems a bit 'brighter'. SD on E* is watcheable and tolerable for those few channels that are SD on both, with the exception of sports. SD and sports just don't seem good at all on both systems with D*'s being worse by a fair margin. I suspect the difference might be signal levels to the TV from the respective HDDVRs more than anything else.
Audio quality is different between the two systems. With D* the separation of channels seems more pronounced on many shows and on some shows, the center (dialog) channel on D* is many times drowned out by the other speakers. E* doesn't seem to be that way though the volume levels on E* are a bit lower than on D*. I suppose the differences are in the decoders and audio pre-amps in the respective gear.
The search function on both the Hopper/SJ and HR44 seems to be pretty much a wash as to power and useability. But E*'s gets very messy as you search for things, D*'s is more mundane, but less cluttered in displaying the results. Frankly a list of shows would be more useful on the Hopper/SJ with search results than are the Icons that the E* programmers are so enamored of, imo.