Well, I chose Dish nearly 10 years ago, because it was cheaper at the time to get the AT250. For me, I wanted a cheap way to get movies, and the AT250 had The Movie Channel and Encore (now Starz Encore), and still does, and it had Boomerang, which my local Xfinity service does not carry to this day, plus a bunch of channels that local cable has added over the years. I stayed for PTAT on the Hopper (even though I'm probably the last sub still using the original Hopper), SiriusXM music in my home, and the overall price difference between out of "new sub" status on both platforms. Directv would cost me more than Dish for what my family watches. The only carrot Directv has is Sunday Ticket, which to me us valued way more than its worth, in comparison to NBA League Pass, NHL Center Ice, and MLB Extra Innings.