Are you saying that if you would purchase a hopper on ebay that had been deactivated from account and unencumbered, or perhaps a new or refurbished one from a dealer and self install, that they won't activate?
That's a good question.
Initially, I asked if I gave them a UID from a used unit from eBay if they could tell me if it was free and clear to be added to my account (would be good info to have before the purchase, right?). The answer was somewhat wishy-washy... but essentially "no". Only one CSR gave this answer, because I only asked the first CSR that particular question.
So then I asked about buying a new one and could I install it myself. That's where the answer shifted to my dish needing to be updated by one of their installers... so no, I couldn't do that. And of course, to get that done, I would need a 2-year commitment.
So in the true tradition of playing "CSR roulette", I called again. I never asked the subsequent CSRs the "used eBay" question... just the install a new one question. They all gave me the dish would have to be upgraded by one of their installers answer. So naturally, I asked about the dish/LNB requirements... I mean... you're telling me it needs to be upgraded... well... upgraded to what?
At that point, they would just tell me again that the dish has to be upgraded by one of their techs and simply not even attempt to answer the question. To this day, I have no idea if my dish really needs upgrading or not. What I do know, is that they've never had access to know what dish I have... via account settings or electronically through the receiver.
So each subsequent CSR would just get hung up on the upgrade your dish via one of their installers and do a 2-year. The new/used thing wasn't even the hang up.
So to summarize, the first CSR discouraged the eBay thing... but then indicated that it didn't matter anyway because of the dish needing to be upgraded. All other CSRs (including the ai chat bot) just went straight to the dish upgrade mantra.
And of course... all roads each and every time, led straight back to a Dish installer and a 2-year commitment.
My final conclusion was that CSR roulette no longer works. Everyone gives the same answer.