Dish now OUT of Bankruptcy - Business as Usual

Advertisements
SpaceX bought wireless spectrum recently that they say penetrates through metal and concete. That's what their direct to cell satellites will supposedly be using.

The Correction: Satellites Still Can't Do It Alone
SpaceX did just buy a massive portfolio of 800 MHz low-band spectrum for $8 billion. Lower frequencies do penetrate buildings, brick, and concrete significantly better than high-frequency satellite bands. [1, 2, 3]

But here is the catch that you missed: SpaceX isn't relying on the satellite to punch through your roof.
Just this week at the DealBook Summit, Elon Musk himself explicitly stated that satellites still struggle to reach indoors, especially if a building has a thick or metal roof. The physics of sending a tiny, low-power cell phone signal all the way up to a satellite in space from inside a concrete structure simply doesn't scale. [1, 2, 3]

How SpaceX Actually Plans to Use It
Instead of trying to blast a signal through your ceiling from orbit, SpaceX's actual blueprint relies on a hybrid network: [1, 2]
  1. Rooftop "Micro" Cell Towers:
    SpaceX just completed the design for a miniature cell tower device that you mount to your roof (similar to a Starlink internet dish). [1]
  2. The Real Transport: This rooftop unit will talk directly to the low Earth orbit satellites outside. [1]
  3. The Terrestrial Hand-off: The unit then beams that low-band 800 MHz cellular signal downward through your roof and walls to connect to your phone. [1, 2]
The Bottom Line:
The fact that SpaceX has to build and manufacture terrestrial rooftop hardware completely validates my original point: space-based satellite networks alone cannot natively penetrate dense indoor structures. [1, 2, 3]
If a subscriber has to put a piece of hardware on their roof just to get cell service inside their own living room, they are still fundamentally supplying their own local infrastructure. [1, 2]
 
I won't even consider Starlink until they deliver competitive pricing and matching performance, meaning a symmetrical 1Gbps connection. Paying a higher premium for worse speeds, less bandwidth, and higher latency makes absolutely no sense.
I've been with Starlink since beta and at the time it was the best service I could get in my area. For $99 a month it was a steal compared to the crappy service I had before with Viasat and Hughesnet. Then Spectrum ran fiber a couple of years ago and of course I instantly switched. My Starlink service has been on the $10 a month Standby plan since then.
 
.I won't even consider Starlink until they deliver competitive pricing and matching performance, meaning a symmetrical 1Gbps connection. Paying a higher premium for worse speeds, less bandwidth, and higher latency makes absolutely no sense.
either would i seeings how i pay 29.99 for a 5 gig fiber pipe with free sunday ticket :). and i pay 19.99 for att internet air for travel. and BTW how long has elon been touting gig speeds :rolleyes: :rolleyes:
 
That assumes Wi-Fi is even available in those dead zones. Since this is a paid service, 100% of the network connection should be delivered directly by the carrier, as it is their primary obligation to provide the signal over their own licensed spectrum. If satellite isn't available, the goal remains a direct connection from the provider one actually pays for—not Wi-Fi, which forces me to supply and pay for my own transport. If I had to rely on Wi-Fi or any other internet connection, I wouldn't even need a mobile phone with a paid subscription service. I could just use Google Voice with a computer, a tablet, a mobile phone without a paid subscription service, or an ATA adapter with a traditional landline phone. It's similar to paying for an internet connection at home and then having to use someone else's internet connection via Wi-Fi to connect to the internet while at home.
And that where Dish network comes into the picture with their cell sites and unused spectrum..
 
And that where Dish network comes into the picture with their cell sites and unused spectrum..

Dish no longer owns them-

The tower companies now own the equipment that Dish Wireless left behind after it abandoned its national 5G network, American Tower President and CEO Steven Vondran revealed Tuesday on the company's Q3 earnings call.

 
either would i seeings how i pay 29.99 for a 5 gig fiber pipe with free sunday ticket :). and i pay 19.99 for att internet air for travel. and BTW how long has elon been touting gig speeds :rolleyes: :rolleyes:
The new version 3 satellites going up now are the ones capable of providing gig speeds. I couldn't care less about having 1 Gbps though. It's overkill for the vast majority of households.
 
I've been with Starlink since beta and at the time it was the best service I could get in my area. For $99 a month it was a steal compared to the crappy service I had before with Viasat and Hughesnet. Then Spectrum ran fiber a couple of years ago and of course I instantly switched. My Starlink service has been on the $10 a month Standby plan since then.
It depends what your choices available are which can change over time. Starlink even at $130/month maxes out at 400Mbps with higher latency and is still less than 50% of the 1.2Gbps I am paying $70/month for. Sonic.net is $49.99 for 10Gbps Fiber but too bad it's not available as people who are 10 blocks over has it available.
 
  • Like
Reactions: charlesrshell
And that where Dish network comes into the picture with their cell sites and unused spectrum..
Even if Dish had successfully built out that network instead of shutting it down and selling it off, the laws of physics would still apply.

Dish's primary low-band coverage relied on 600 MHz spectrum. While 600 MHz penetrates buildings significantly better than high-frequency bands, it still suffers massive signal attenuation when hitting heavy concrete, brick, or radiant-barrier metal insulation. No cellular spectrum on Earth natively delivers a perfect indoor signal into deep dead zones or dense basements without massive terrestrial density—meaning they would have had to put a macro cell or small cell on practically every block to eliminate those indoor dead zones entirely.
Whether it's Dish's old 600 MHz spectrum, Verizon's 700 MHz, or SpaceX's new 800 MHz, space-to-terrestrial signals still die when hitting dense indoor structures. The carrier is still shifting the burden onto the subscriber to step outside or plug in an indoor booster just to get what they pay for.

Bruce is right. As American Tower CEO Steven Vondran confirmed on their Q3 earnings call, a bankruptcy court order officially granted tower companies full ownership of the abandoned Dish Wireless 5G radios and antennas 'free and clear'. Dish's physical radio access network (RAN) is completely dead. [1, 2]
Guess who is actively negotiating with the tower companies right now to rent or buy that abandoned Dish hardware? SpaceX. [1, 2]

SpaceX has been trying to secure access to up to 80,000 terrestrial cell sites across the country because they know their direct-to-cell satellites cannot scale or natively penetrate indoor concrete and metal roofs on their own. [1]

So to wrap this all up:
  1. Dish Network threw in the towel, defaulted on their leases, and left their gear behind.
  2. The Tower Companies now own thousands of stranded radios.
  3. SpaceX has to try to scoop up that same terrestrial hardware to build out a hybrid ground network just to make their satellite coverage viable indoors. [1, 2, 3]
The laws of physics won. Space-based signals alone cannot natively blast through dense home insulation and walls. If a mobile subscriber is forced to fall back on their own Wi-Fi or local rooftop hardware to route a connection, the carrier is still offloading the technical burden and costs onto the customer. While this will solve outdoor dead zones, it still won't solve the problem of getting a native signal inside buildings or vehicles—including public transit and rideshare vehicles like trains, buses, taxis, Ubers, and Lyfts—when there is a dead spot.
 
Last edited:
The new version 3 satellites going up now are the ones capable of providing gig speeds. I couldn't care less about having 1 Gbps though. It's overkill for the vast majority of households.
Saying 1 Gbps is 'overkill' completely ignores both the physics of satellite bandwidth and how internet usage evolves.
First, when SpaceX or Amazon talks about 'gigabit speeds' on newer low Earth orbit networks, they are referring to the total aggregate bandwidth of the beam shared across an entire cell sector, not individual user speeds. Because satellite is a shared medium, that capacity is split among hundreds of active users simultaneously, causing speeds to fluctuate heavily during peak hours. In fact, for Amazon's newly rebranded satellite network (Amazon Leo, formerly Project Kuiper), true gigabit performance is explicitly locked behind their massive 'Leo Ultra' enterprise-grade terminal (measuring 19x30 inches) and tested under empty, ideal conditions. The standard residential terminal that average home users will actually get is capped at a maximum download speed of around 400 Mbps.
Second, only looking at downloads misses the real bottleneck: upload speeds. Starlink's uploads are notoriously weak (often hovering between 10–25 Mbps). Symmetrical gigabit connections aren't about overkill; they are about eliminating asymmetrical choking when running high-bandwidth applications, heavy multi-device smart homes, or massive data uploads concurrently.
Finally, the 'overkill' argument never ages well. Decades ago, people thought a DS1/T1 line at 1.544 Mbps was an absurd amount of overkill that a single household could never saturate. Then companies moved to massive DS3/T3 lines at 45 Mbps, which were meant to support entire corporate headquarters with hundreds of employees. Today, a single 4K video stream and a couple of active smart home devices will completely choke a 45 Mbps pipe. Bandwidth demands scale exponentially. Settling for lower bandwidth, weak uploads, and high latency at a higher premium makes zero sense when symmetrical terrestrial networks deliver far better performance for less money.
 
  • Like
Reactions: charlesrshell

Interesting - got a NEW H3 as an RA replacement