Spears & Munsil HD Benchmark, 2nd Edition

Ilya

XXI Century Explorer
Original poster
Staff member
HERE TO HELP YOU!
Lifetime Supporter
Feb 16, 2004
31,119
19,024
NE OH



Seattle, WA, April 24, 2013 – Stacey Spears and Don Munsil, acclaimed creators of the Spears & Munsil High Definition Benchmark Blu-ray Disc, are pleased to announce the release of the Spears & Munsil HD Benchmark, 2nd Edition. The first edition of this disc was recommended by the New York Times, Widescreen Review, Secrets of Home Theater and High Fidelity®, and many other print and online publications. The second edition adds even more features and patterns and sets a new bar for the term “state of the art.” The Spears & Munsil disc is the first (and at this time only) disc to offer stereoscopic patterns for calibrating and testing 3D televisions. It has audio level and phase tests created using the latest noise-shaping algorithms. And for the professional or advanced enthusiast it contains a complete set of patterns suitable for precisely calibrating contrast, grayscale, gamut, and other settings using test equipment.

“We didn’t just want to add a few new features here and there,” said co-creator Stacey Spears, “we went back to the drawing board and re-thought every pattern.” There are more than twice as many patterns on this new disc as on the previous disc, covering every aspect of home theater testing and calibration.

Like the previous edition, the Spears & Munsil HD Benchmark, 2nd Edition uses patterns created from scratch using Spears & Munsil’s own in-house software. “We still feel that there isn’t anything else out there that meets our quality standards across the board,” said co-creator Don Munsil. “So every pattern was created from scratch, using custom software, in the native color space that is most appropriate for that pattern. All of the scaling and color conversion was done using our own software as well.”

The disc includes new editions of some of the favorite patterns from the previous disc, plus many new ones that are exclusive to Spears & Munsil. “We’ve created what we think is the best pattern for setting color and tint ever made,” said Spears. “The problem with the classic color bars pattern is that it was designed for broadcast engineers and is confusing for the new user. We re-thought the entire pattern from scratch and made something anyone can use, with step-by-step instructions right on the pattern. We did the same re-thinking for essentially every pattern we made, though the classic patterns are on there as well for the purist.”

“The enthusiasts and power users took to our previous disc right away,” said Munsil, “but we got feedback that the disc was still too daunting for inexperienced users who’ve never tried to calibrate a television before. We tried to address that with even more comprehensive guides and help in this disc, and we think we have created a disc that allows someone with no home theater experience to jump right in and get a basic calibration in less than an hour.”

The power users have not been forgotten, however. The new edition also contains patterns suitable for the professional calibrator or serious amateur who wants a complete suite of test patterns usable with spectroradiometers and colorimeters. “The people who tested our professional patterns perform calibrations for Hollywood studios and famous movie directors. These people are the pickiest customers you could ask for,” said Spears.

The Spears & Munsil HD Benchmark, 2nd Edition is the first test disc to contain tests and demo material in 3D, for users with a 3D Blu-ray Disc player and 3D display. In addition to patterns for testing the 3D features of the display, the disc contains a full set of 2D calibration patterns that are encoded in 3D mode so the user can do a calibration of the 3D modes on the display. “Most televisions have completely different settings for 2D and 3D modes,” said Spears. “Calibrating one doesn’t affect the other. Without these patterns, you can’t really ensure your 3D movies look as good as the rest of your video.”

The Spears & Munsil HD Benchmark, 2nd Edition is available from OPPO Digital, http://www.oppodigital.com, and Amazon.com, http://www.amazon.com. List price is $29.97.
 
Id guess mine will be here mid week, I ordered yesterday. I love their 1st disc, and intend on using their equal energy patterns to calibrate my set. Also nice to see more patterns in the video processing. Ive been email Stacy off and on for a year waiting on the disc. He shot me a heads up last night so I pulled the trigger.
 
Yes I saw that. Not Prime-eligible yet! ;)
 
I don't think the first one was ever prime eligible either. It was sold through Oppo on Amazon.

S~

OK. Now we're in the right thread. Really bad week. Guess I can't have more than one thread open at a time.
 
Got it in today, hope to mess around with it tomorrow and see the pattern layout. Will try and calibrate my VT50 with the equal energy patterns Fri night.
 
I changed my mind on the equal energy patterns, I've read a lot of input from calibrators that there is no science behind these APL patterns. Plasma will have some fluctuation between windows size, more so for gamma, but calibrators like Chad B have found grayscale variances between non apl and apl, so Im staying away from these APL patterns for now.

All that being said, the added test patterns on the disc are great, I mean there are a ton.

Review
 
Thats one thing Joe Kane does and does well. He is so good at explaining things that even as a newbie he can explain things so you will understand them.

Although meeting with Joe in person do think twice about asking him a simple question... he loves this stuff so much that he could talk for hours just giving you the answer for your simple question.
 
I see it's now Fulfilled by Amazon an is Prime-eligible.

Sent from my iPad 3 using SatelliteGuys
 
Its a very complicated pattern set, almost too much. Ive found myself using the 1st version for standard chroma/luma tests, 24p handling, sharpness, contrast, brightness and overscan. There are some good specific patterns to find useful if you need them, but for a quick overview of how the display performs with say 720, 1080i and 1080p, the old version is still my choice.

I was going to try the equal energy patterns, but most recommendations for the Panasonic plasma is 10-15% sized windows, not APL. To be quite frank, ive yet to prefer an APL pattern cal over a 10% window.
 
I just got around to calibrating with the equal energy patterns on this disc, and the results look quite good. I need to further eval, but Ive been experimenting with different methods on the VT50 of late, and run into issues with green blacks, red blacks and red skin tones. Especially in Warm 2, it does not track grayscale well below 10% stimuli, and thats an issue. Ive kept a few television shows on my DVR that Ive noticed issues with in the past couple of weeks, so I can review them after a calibration run. So far, these results seems to alleviated the problems Ive seen. The patterns are nice and provided very consistent results. The one odd thing is the VT50 requires you to use the 2.4 gamma setting in the menu to get a 2.25 gamma with normal windows, with the equal energy patterns it was an almost flat 2.4 out of the gate, I was shocked. Also, with 10% windows you can get the footlamberts up over 40 normally, but with these patterns it would not go over 34.5fL regardless of 85 contrast, or 100. I'm no expert on APL patterns so I cant explain them but a lot of folks are starting to swear by them for plasma.

The color patterns dont offer a full range of varied saturations, they are all 100%. I used 75% Amplitude and 100% Saturation which is what Id always used off AVS709, people seem to think its more representative than 100% amplitude.

Grayscale (dE less than 1, avg Gamma 2.41, avg Color Temp 6512)
VT50SpearsDiscGrayscale062113_zpse368c3b6.jpg


Gamma
VT50SpearsDiscGamma062113_zps9a8cea61.jpg


Color
VT50SpearsDiscColor062113_zps0e5325ee.jpg
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 0, Members: 0, Guests: 0)

Who Read This Thread (Total Members: 1)