Or he knew exactly what he was doing making those claims...
Why do you take such joy vilifying people like this? It can't make you feel better about the bad situation TurboHD customers find themselves in. I'd rather assume good ol' fashion incompetence than evil intent from the beginning. After all, we're talking about predicting the future here.
If you were Charlie, you might assume other execs could be persuaded to behave reasonably and
embrace an HD-only package. Or failing that, you might expect that money would smooth over differences (hence the big price increase for TurboHD customers), and allow the Turbo packages to go forward as intended. Only after protracted negotiations fail miserably do you discover that your fellow execs are brain-dead idiots trying to stop the clock and force their particular HD+SD bundling scheme on Dish no matter the consequences. In the end, I applaud Dish for trying to innovate with HD-only packages, even if the brain dead idiots succeed for now. And I have to give the brain dead idiots a really big

: for trying to stop the clock. May they find themselves unemployed rather soon and unexpectedly.