TV Indoor Digital Antenna questions (1 Viewer)

MortimerWestinghouse

Thread Starter
New Member
Apr 5, 2017
3
1
NYC
Hi there - I'm a recent indoor digital antenna buyer and budding OTA enthusiast. I live on the 4th floor of an apartment in Brooklyn, about 5-10 miles south of tens of OTA channels broadcasting from towers in Manhattan and within 30 miles of attainable channels in New Jersey and Long Island. I'm getting 75+ channels on a bad day and close to 100 on a good day.

I've experimented with a couple different indoor digital antennas - a 35 mile radius and a 50 mile radius antenna. I have a few questions for someone out there, as I am eager to learn more about how these antennas work and hoping that one of you guys can help.

-There's a channel about 7 miles away that broadcasts from the Empire State Building that I can't seem to reliably get. I get lots of other channels that transmit from the ESB, but I can't get this one. Why would that be?

-Is there a reason why a 35 mile antenna would get certain channels that a 50 mile antenna wouldn't? I noticed that I ended up getting slightly more channels with the 35 than the 50, even though the quality overall is better with the 50. Do antennas with more range sacrifice the ability to locate certain low-power channels that are closer?

-I've only used the flat antennas that look like mousepads. In order to better get the channels that are in NJ and LI to the east and west, would an indoor antenna with old-school rabbit ears or a curved antenna (like the Mohu Curve) likely perform better than the flat antennas?

I realize these are pretty basic questions - like I said, I'm really curious about how this technology works and have been reading up a bunch about it so I'm hoping that someone can help me along here. Thanks in advance.
 

comfortably_numb

Dogs have owners, cats have staff
Pub Member / Supporter
Nov 30, 2011
11,578
12,365
Missouri/Kansas
Hi there - I'm a recent indoor digital antenna buyer and budding OTA enthusiast. I live on the 4th floor of an apartment in Brooklyn, about 5-10 miles south of tens of OTA channels broadcasting from towers in Manhattan and within 30 miles of attainable channels in New Jersey and Long Island. I'm getting 75+ channels on a bad day and close to 100 on a good day.

I've experimented with a couple different indoor digital antennas - a 35 mile radius and a 50 mile radius antenna. I have a few questions for someone out there, as I am eager to learn more about how these antennas work and hoping that one of you guys can help.

-There's a channel about 7 miles away that broadcasts from the Empire State Building that I can't seem to reliably get. I get lots of other channels that transmit from the ESB, but I can't get this one. Why would that be?

-Is there a reason why a 35 mile antenna would get certain channels that a 50 mile antenna wouldn't? I noticed that I ended up getting slightly more channels with the 35 than the 50, even though the quality overall is better with the 50. Do antennas with more range sacrifice the ability to locate certain low-power channels that are closer?

-I've only used the flat antennas that look like mousepads. In order to better get the channels that are in NJ and LI to the east and west, would an indoor antenna with old-school rabbit ears or a curved antenna (like the Mohu Curve) likely perform better than the flat antennas?

I realize these are pretty basic questions - like I said, I'm really curious about how this technology works and have been reading up a bunch about it so I'm hoping that someone can help me along here. Thanks in advance.

Welcome to the forum! Glad to see another fellow OTA enthusiast. Could you run a TV Fool report on your location from www.tvfool.com and post your results here? That will help us point you in the right direction. :)


Sent from my iPhone using the SatelliteGuys app!
 

boba

SatelliteGuys Master
Dec 12, 2003
11,350
1,033
Dorchester, TX.
With 75-100 channels are you missing something? Saying you are getting 125 channels might sound impressive, but if you are only watching 10 of them your wasting your money.
 

comfortably_numb

Dogs have owners, cats have staff
Pub Member / Supporter
Nov 30, 2011
11,578
12,365
Missouri/Kansas
With 75-100 channels are you missing something? Saying you are getting 125 channels might sound impressive, but if you are only watching 10 of them your wasting your money.

No harm in trying to get as many channels as one can. Like him, this is a hobby for me, too, and I like to experiment with different antennas to see what I can get. If he wants to spend his money, more power to him. I can think of worse things to waste money on..


Sent from my iPhone using the SatelliteGuys app!
 

MortimerWestinghouse

Thread Starter
New Member
Apr 5, 2017
3
1
NYC
Sure thing. Here's my report.

WJLP is 6 miles away and yet I can't seem to reliably get it in alongside other channels (like WNXY, WBQM, WDVB etc.) that are even closer that I can't get in at all, whereas I have relatively few issues getting WLIW from 29 miles away. I don't really get it, so I'm just kind of curious how this all works and what I might be able to do about it.

And yeah - living in NYC, I realize that we have a wealth of OTA options, and it's not like it makes a big difference in the grand scheme of things. It's just kind of a hobby to see how many channels I can get - the most I've ever reached is like 95. I know that the possibility exists to hit 100, and it'd be pretty sweet if I could do it. :)
 

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2017-04-05 at 8.12.29 PM.png
    Screen Shot 2017-04-05 at 8.12.29 PM.png
    127.5 KB · Views: 126
  • Like
Reactions: comfortably_numb

comfortably_numb

Dogs have owners, cats have staff
Pub Member / Supporter
Nov 30, 2011
11,578
12,365
Missouri/Kansas
Sure thing. Here's my report.

WJLP is 6 miles away and yet I can't seem to reliably get it in alongside other channels (like WNXY, WBQM, WDVB etc.) that are even closer that I can't get in at all, whereas I have relatively few issues getting WLIW from 29 miles away. I don't really get it, so I'm just kind of curious how this all works and what I might be able to do about it.

And yeah - living in NYC, I realize that we have a wealth of OTA options, and it's not like it makes a big difference in the grand scheme of things. It's just kind of a hobby to see how many channels I can get - the most I've ever reached is like 95. I know that the possibility exists to hit 100, and it'd be pretty sweet if I could do it. :)

Ah, I see WJLP is a VHF-LO station on channel 3. That's probably the issue. Those flat digital antennas don't really do a good job handling VHF-LO.


Sent from my iPhone using the SatelliteGuys app!
 

primestar31

SatelliteGuys Master
Lifetime Supporter
Mar 15, 2005
9,616
6,144
Beta Omicron Delta III
Sure thing. Here's my report.

WJLP is 6 miles away and yet I can't seem to reliably get it in alongside other channels (like WNXY, WBQM, WDVB etc.) that are even closer that I can't get in at all, whereas I have relatively few issues getting WLIW from 29 miles away. I don't really get it, so I'm just kind of curious how this all works and what I might be able to do about it.

And yeah - living in NYC, I realize that we have a wealth of OTA options, and it's not like it makes a big difference in the grand scheme of things. It's just kind of a hobby to see how many channels I can get - the most I've ever reached is like 95. I know that the possibility exists to hit 100, and it'd be pretty sweet if I could do it. :)

WJLP is a LOW band VHF station, it's on RF3. That means you need a large (due to long wavelength at that frequency) outdoor low band vhf antenna to get it. It's also very affected by any strong FM radio stations, and any electrical interference nearby.

The little patch UHF antennas can't get it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: comfortably_numb

comfortably_numb

Dogs have owners, cats have staff
Pub Member / Supporter
Nov 30, 2011
11,578
12,365
Missouri/Kansas
Do you have access to the roof of your building? If they'd let you put even a small outdoor antenna out there, or just outside the window of your apartment, you could probably pull it off. VHF-LO is kind of a specialty niche, I don't have any VHF-LO channels here, so I'll defer to the experts on what you could use to pull those stations in ;)


Sent from my iPhone using the SatelliteGuys app!
 

harshness

SatelliteGuys Master
May 5, 2007
16,698
2,754
Salem, OR
Distance as the crow flies from the broadcast antennas is only part of the equation. If you're on the far side of your building, your "distance" goes up significantly because the building materials absorb the signal.

There can also be issues stemming from signals bouncing off other buildings that interfere with the signal direct from the tower. Sometimes you have to make your antenna setup "less powerful" in order to pick up very close stations that are bouncing from many directions (multi-path).

VHF low demands an antenna with long elements (rabbit ears are better than most give them credit for). Mud flap and similar "flat" antennas are really only ideal for channels 14 and up regardless of what the marketroids claim. The other disadvantage to "flat" antennas is that they are not particularly directional and as such, are much more susceptible to multi-path.
 
  • Like
Reactions: comfortably_numb

MortimerWestinghouse

Thread Starter
New Member
Apr 5, 2017
3
1
NYC
A-ha. This all makes sense now. Thanks for your collective wisdom - I didn't know about the VHF Low distinction.

Are there indoor antennas that are particularly good for VHF Low channels? Like one of those indoor antennas with rabbit ears, or some such? I'm fortunately on the north side of my building, with a relatively unobstructed view of the broadcast towers in question (I can see them both from my windows). I don't have roof access to my building, but I probably could hang some kind of small outdoor antenna out of my window somehow.
 

Trip

RabbitEars Webmaster
Staff member
HERE TO HELP YOU!
Jun 21, 2008
1,322
755
Alexandria, VA, US
Sure thing. Here's my report.

WJLP is 6 miles away and yet I can't seem to reliably get it in alongside other channels (like WNXY, WBQM, WDVB etc.) that are even closer that I can't get in at all, whereas I have relatively few issues getting WLIW from 29 miles away. I don't really get it, so I'm just kind of curious how this all works and what I might be able to do about it.

As others have noted, WJLP is on low-VHF and will require a real antenna to receive. At my grandmother's house in Fair Lawn, NJ, I can just barely decode it with rabbit ears, and even the antenna in the attic doesn't do much with it. (You can see the live reception from that location at this address: https://m.rabbitears.info/index.php?request=tvdx_grid&tid=10343612&tno=1 )

WDVB-CD is side-mounted on the Empire State Building and you're in the spot where their directional antenna is falling off. It may not be receivable depending on where it's mounted and other specifics like that which aren't part of the FCC database.

WBQM-LD was running an empty transport stream last time I was in the area. It was on the air, but broadcasting no programming. If that's still the case, you could very well be receiving the signal but not seeing it on your TV.

To my knowledge, WNXY-LD simulcasts with WXNY-LD and WNYX-LD and is thus completely redundant. I wouldn't waste any time on it, and I was unable to confirm that it is on the air last time I was in the area.

- Trip
 
  • Like
Reactions: comfortably_numb

SatPhreak

SatelliteGuys Pro
Apr 19, 2007
941
138
Thunder Bay, ON
You might be able to get it with rabbit ears. I live in a market with 3 vhf low channels (2, 4 and 9), am about 10 miles to both transmitters (2 and 4 are on the same transmitter), but I can't get channel 2. My rabbit ears can get 4 and 9. I think my rabbit ears are just a few inches short of what channel 2 needs.

Sent from my SM-N900W8 using the SatelliteGuys app!
 

navychop

Member of the Month - July 2014!
Pub Member / Supporter
Lifetime Supporter
Jul 20, 2005
51,892
16,814
Northern VA
A few inches short? Do what we used to do- either of the following. The first one works best:

A. Have a small child stand next to TV holding the end of one antenna.

B. Put aluminum foil on both ends of the antenna.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 0, Members: 0, Guests: 0)

Latest posts

Top