Folks, I went ahead and gave Xfinity a try. The internet so far is fine, much faster than Uverse, but that has nothing to do with DISH. As for TV, Xfinity has a few more channels and a better VOD selection, I think. But Lucky hit the nail on the head with his earlier post on this thread: "On the box my in-laws have, one of my biggest issues with it is the guide. I hate the fact that once you get to a channel you have to select watch in HD and then it flips you to another station. Other than that, the set top box they have is the worst thing I have ever used. Remote response is horrible, menus are extremely outdated and in my opinion it is not good at all. Comcast internet can be great but I would never pick up cable as my TV provider." Agree 100%, who would have thought the channel guide would be a deal breaker? The channel guide shows every channel, you can't delete the channels you are not interested in or even the ones you are not subscribed to. And the lineup has no logic, unlike DISH where all the ESPN and sports channels are pretty much together, all the kids channels are together, etc, on Xfinity they are all mixed up. "Keep dish. Switch to comcast internet. Go with Ooma for your home phone." I have already receieved email asking me to come back, with $30 off for 10 months. Kind of tempting.
smjbh5 may have the best idea: DISH for TV, Ooma (I have OBI100, similar) for phone, Xfinity for internet.