I loved my DT Series 2 Tivo.
But analog cable ($30/mo) + Tivo ($13/mo) isn't as much a value as DishHD, VIP722, cinemax for $42/mo w/a 24-mo commitment.
.
The only thing I'm missing is my regional sports in SD and, in my opinion, a slightly more intuitive, more reliable Tivo DVR.
What do I gain? HD/DD5.1, a 3rd OTA tuner, an HD DVR, modulated dual mode, 350GB of storage, no upfront box fee.
Again, my Tivo was great. But the DishHD package, cinemax, and VIP722 just blows anything else out there away.