I would automatically disquailify Bonds and Pujols from the conversation. Perhaps Griffey too. Sorry Junior, luv ya but you should have hung around with different guys.
I don't think I would have any of those three on my list anyway. Pujols over Jimmy Foxx and Bill Terry? Bonds (and Stargell???) over Ted Williams, Ty Cobb and Hank Aaron? Griffey over Dimaggio and Mantle?
Lots of home cooking here too.
Mazeroski over Rogers Hornsby and Jackie Robinson???
Clemente over Reggie Jackson?
At least you're a little more objective than HDMM will be. He likes to do things from a 'Cleveland perspective'.
I'm sure somehow Jim Thome will make his list...
Sandra