Social Feed

Main Feed My Feed
G
gordonkearse
Last reply · posted in C-BAND Satellite Discussion

Solid versus mesh dish for ku

Was just viewing the previous thread and didn't really want to hijack it. So has anyone experimented with solid versus mesh dishes for ku?

Right now I'm noticing my ku quality is significantly lower than c-band quality on my 10 foot perfect ten mesh dish. I've adjusted and adjusted the lnb.

I've considered putting up a smaller 6 foot solid dish to compare the two for ku signal strength and quality.
Read more
9 Replies · 10677 views
Load Replies (9) Reply Legacy View
B.J.
B.J.
Unless the mesh dish is very very old, I'm confident that the mesh is small enough that it is 99% as efficient as a solid surface. But as the above responses mention, shape of the dish is really a critical factor, and it's very common that a mesh dish doesn't have very good shape. {Actually, the shape should in theory be an elliptical shape, not parabolic, but this is a trick statement, because at these distances, they're essentially the same.}
Also, as mentioned above, having the focal distance set properly, is very important, because with Ku, if the focal distance is set wrong, the signal pattern will look more like a donut than a spot.
But the main reason for responding is that even though most C/Ku feeds don't illuminate well for Ku, and the dish shape may not be perfect, and the focal distance might be off a bit, since the Ku sats are generally more powerful than the C-band sats, and since a dish theoretically will have a higher gain on Ku than C-band, and since a big dish will generally have more resolution to reject adjacent satellite interferrence, you'd really expect Ku performance to be better than C-band, unless the dish is really in bad shape.
In MY case, when my 10' mesh dish was new, it performed pretty well on Ku. Significantly better than a 3' solid dish, and much better than a 6' mesh dish I have. However over the years, it has gotten dented and warped, and it now gives extremely poor performance on Ku. I've tried all sorts of things to get my dish back in shape, but so far nothing's worked. I think that when the weather gets better, I'm going to pull out some of the mesh panels and see if I can flatten them, but I'm not real optimistic that this will help. I really think that I need a new dish.
Read more
Reply
C
caddata
B.J. said:
......Actually, the shape should in theory be an elliptical shape, not parabolic......
Click to expand...

Not true. The reflecting surface is parabolic in shape. All parallel waves (electromagnetic, light, or sound) striking it's surface are reflected to one point, travel the same distance, and arrive in phase with eachother at one focal point.

An elliptical surface has two focal points, reflected waves travel unequal distances to those focal points, and arrive out of phase with eachother. Elliptical reflectors are used for lights and parabolic reflectors are used for satellite dishes.

Any reference to elliptical when discussing satellite dishes is in reference to the shape of the outer permiter of an offset focal point dish. Prime focus dishes have a round perimiter.
Read more
Reply
B.J.
B.J.
caddata said:
Not true. The reflecting surface is parabolic in shape. All parallel waves (electromagnetic, light, or sound) striking it's surface are reflected to one point, travel the same distance, and arrive in phase with eachother at one focal point.

An elliptical surface has two focal points, reflected waves travel unequal distances to those focal points, and arrive out of phase with eachother. Elliptical reflectors are used for lights and parabolic reflectors are used for satellite dishes.

Any reference to elliptical when discussing satellite dishes is in reference to the shape of the outer permiter of an offset focal point dish. Prime focus dishes have a round perimiter.
Click to expand...

Well, I kind of agree, and kind of disagree.

But the reason why I contend that it should be an elliptical surface is because a parabolic surface will focus parallel rays to a common focal point. An elliptical surface will focus rays which come from 1 specific point, which just happens to be the other focal point of the ellipse. Ie an ellipse has 2 focal points, which are often used to draw them via a string tied between them. For an elliptical surface, RF coming from one focus will be reflected to the other focus. A parabolic dish only focuses to a single point if the object is infinitely far away, and the sats are at a finite distance.


I think I see what you're saying though about the phase issue, although the drawing via a string analogy would seem to suggest that it WOULD be in phase, but even if it is out of phase, I guess that means that neither a parabola nor an ellipse will work perfectly. A parabola won't focus to a point, and an ellipse may be slightly out of phase. But the real bottom line is that an ellipse that big is essentially the same as a parabola, so there isn't much difference.

I hope I don't confuse things by having edited this about 6 times. I've gone back and forth between disagreeing and agreeing multiple times, which means this is a really interesting topic. :)
Read more
Reply
Anole
Anole
back on topic:

gordonkearse said:
Was just viewing the previous thread and didn't really want to hijack it. So has anyone experimented with solid versus mesh dishes for ku?

Right now I'm noticing my ku quality is significantly lower than c-band quality on my 10 foot perfect ten mesh dish. I've adjusted and adjusted the lnb.

I've considered putting up a smaller 6 foot solid dish to compare the two for ku signal strength and quality.
Click to expand...
I believe there are a number of considerations to getting a good Ku signal.

- most Ku signals are sufficiently powerful, to be received in their target area on a modest sized dish.
- some Ku signals have neighboring satellites spewing interfering signals on a nearby frequency.
- unfortunately, downlink signals can be attenuated by weather
- uplink power on most FTA doesn't seem to be monitored to provide constant downlink signal

- dish surface accuracy at Ku is of paramount importance
- transmit-certified Ku dishes may be able to provide a cleaner signal by virtue of sharper focus

So, if your 10 foot dish uses a large vs small mesh, sags or has other imperfections, is equipped with a non-optimal feedhorn, or is aimed at easy vs difficult Ku birds, it may or may not get the job done.
On the other hand, a surplus 6' Prodelin, taken from 2-way service, and outfitted with the proper feedhorn, -might- blow the doors off a 10 or 12 foot BUD... for Ku.

The point being, there are a lot of factors to take into consideration.
Focusing on just one or two, can lead to inconclusive results.
Of course, going ballistic, and spending $5000 on your Ku dish, is just as bad. :rolleyes:

Maybe look into how users report their 1.2m dishes perform on the satellites you watch.
That might be a good solution... to size, weight, matching feeds, motorization, etc.
Read more
Reply
C
caddata
B.J.:

I don''t want to hijack this post by concentrating on the shape of a reflective surface, but I can't let the things you're saying go by without comment.

How'd you get so confused on this subject? There's never been, and never will be, a "dish" antenna manufactured with an elliptical reflecting surface. Show me the specifications of a "dish" antenna that states the reflective surface is elliptical in shape.

Any reference to "elliptical" is related to the shape of the rim (offset feed as opposed to prime focus which is usually round). The elliptical shaped rim can be used to limit adjacent interfering signals even on prime focus antennas.

B.J. said:
......A parabolic dish only focuses to a single point if the object is infinitely far away, and the sats are at a finite distance......
Click to expand...
A parabolic "dish" focuses all parallel signals (electromagnetic, light, or sound) to the same focal point, whether the source of the signal is 6" or an infinite distance away.
Read more
Reply
G
gordonkearse
I've got to admit that most of you have thought long and hard over which dishes work the best and why -- at least in theory.

And so often I see photographs which show the same people with multiple types of c and ku band dishes. I guess they are experimenting, too!

I've thought long and hard about whether it was even worth it to set up old 10 foot fiberglass dishes. Many appear very heavy duty. But I sometimes wonder how much time has degraded them. Indeed, they could be affected by material breakdown or become just a little warped.

Your discussions keep bringing me back to the issue of focal point. I have still never checked my BUD for this. I'm sure I'll get to it at some point.

I do notice a few small dings due to sleet over the years. My ten footer is a 1993 model so I don't really expect it to be perfect anymore.

Thanks for the input.
Read more
Reply
truckracer
truckracer
I have a 7.5' and 10' mesh dishes both with c and ku. I have a solid fiberglass commercial prodelin 1.2M receive/transmit dish. Both my big mesh dishes seem to perform equally as well and better on some ku sats than the dedicated ku dish. i know this sort of goes against the grain but its has been my experience.

i am using corotor II feedhorns with norsat lnbs for both c and ku.
my ku lnbs are PLL type.

i was using the ku lnb that is mounted on the transmit radio on the prodelin.

If your mesh big dish is straight and not warped or sagging, properly aimed with a nice line of sight..it willl peg the signal meter in most cases on ku.
Read more
Reply
View all replies (9)
TFLEV
· posted in TFLEV

This New Zeekr 7GT Is Bargain-Priced Taycan Alternative You've Never Heard Of!

Time for another AWESOME video from TFL Electric Vehicles!


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rVPpv2ZvbFU


Direct YouTube Link - This New Zeekr 7GT Is Bargain-Priced Taycan Alternative You've Never Heard Of!
Read more
0 Replies · 5 views
Replies Reply Legacy View
Scott Greczkowski
Scott Greczkowski
Staff member HERE TO HELP YOU! Cutting Edge
Last reply · posted in The Chit Chat Club

Song Name Game Part 3!

Sometimes a thread gets so many posts in it that is can cause issues for the server so that why today we introduce The Song Name Game Part 3!

So let the game continue!

The last song was added by Bobby who posted...

One Meat Ball - Andrews Sisters

CONTINUE ON AND HAVE FUN! WELCOME HOME TO SATELLITEGUYS.US!

Here are the original rules for the game as posted by WebbyDude back in 2006. http://www.satelliteguys.us/threads/68645-Song-Name-Game

Just name a song title and the band who performed it. The next person does the same thing, but needs to list a song title or band name which includes a word from the previous entry. Pick songs from any genre.

Example:

Long Live Rock and Roll -- Rainbow

Rainbow in the Dark -- Dio

Another example:

Ride the Lightning -- Metallica

Lightning Strikes -- Ozzy Osbourne


Get it?


An additional note: we all know that song titles, sometimes, use profane words. Because this is a family friendly website it is advised that you clean up that title up a bit. This is accomplished by using something like sh!t instead of the real word. Thanks....
Read more
68664 Replies · 2680670 views
Load Replies (68664) Reply Legacy View
  • Like
Reactions: c-spand
sdfntx
sdfntx
Take It as It Comes - Steve Winwood
Read more
Reply
  • Like
Reactions: EatMyVolts
long_time_Dish
long_time_Dish
Take The Money and Run - Steve Miller Band
Read more
Reply
  • Like
Reactions: ClarkGable and RaiderPower
EatMyVolts
EatMyVolts
Run Joe -- Louis Jordan and his Tympany Five
Read more
Reply
  • Like
Reactions: Bobby
long_time_Dish
long_time_Dish
The Long Run - The Eagles
Read more
Reply
  • Like
Reactions: ClarkGable
ClarkGable
ClarkGable
Long Train Runnin' - The Doobie Brothers
Read more
Reply
View all replies (68664)
meStevo
meStevo
Lifetime Supporter
Last reply · posted in TV Shows

The Diplomat (Netflix)

Starting a thread klang !

After an amazing first 2 seasons and an 8 episode 3rd season still coming this year, season 4 has now been greenlit.

Keri Russell Wow GIF by NETFLIX
Read more
12 Replies · 1023 views
Load Replies (12) Reply Legacy View
  • Like
Reactions: klang
K
klang
Finished season 3 last night. Still one of my favorite shows.

Anyone else wonder if there might be something else going on with Callum? Seems to me he has too much access to Russian intelligence.
Read more
Reply
meStevo
meStevo
One episode into season 4 that dropped today...

Jon Stewart Popcorn GIF
Read more
Reply
  • Like
Reactions: NYDutch
meStevo
meStevo
Renewed for season 5.
Read more
Reply
K
klang
Finished 4 last night. Great stuff.

They do like to end each season with a Bang!
Read more
Reply
KAB
KAB
klang said:
Finished 4 last night. Great stuff.

They do like to end each season with a Bang!
Click to expand...
Great ending, but it ran in circles most of the season.
Read more
Reply
View all replies (12)
M
mheisen
Last reply · posted in DISH Network Support Forum

Hopper 3 with Hopper plus internet connection problems

Over the past few weeks, I have had problems connecting to streaming services (Netflix, HBO et al). When I go to the TV's native Channels, I have no problem. The Dish internet troubleshooter shows I have a good internet connection. I'm wondering whether it's an issue with my internet provider or a problem with the Dish software on the Hopper Plus. Anyone else seeing this?
Read more
5 Replies · 210 views
Load Replies (5) Reply Legacy View
Almighty1
Almighty1
mheisen said:
Over the past few weeks, I have had problems connecting to streaming services (Netflix, HBO et al). When I go to the TV's native Channels, I have no problem. The Dish internet troubleshooter shows I have a good internet connection. I'm wondering whether it's an issue with my internet provider or a problem with the Dish software on the Hopper Plus. Anyone else seeing this?
Click to expand...
I have a DISH Hopper 3 (Software H713) with Hopper Plus (Software P15403). I have not tried streaming services but I primarily watch TVB Jadeworld international package which is only available by streaming and when I have an issue, I usually have to go to a non-streaming satellite channel first before the streaming channels will work again. What software versions do you have and what is the error message if any are showing on your screen? or is that Dish downloading logo just stuck and never finishes?
Read more
Reply
  • Like
Reactions: charlesrshell
M
mheisen
Almighty1 said:
I have a DISH Hopper 3 (Software H713) with Hopper Plus (Software P15403). I have not tried streaming services but I primarily watch TVB Jadeworld international package which is only available by streaming and when I have an issue, I usually have to go to a non-streaming satellite channel first before the streaming channels will work again. What software versions do you have and what is the error message if any are showing on your screen? or is that Dish downloading logo just stuck and never finishes?
Click to expand...
I'm on H713 on the Hopper and P15403 on the Hopper Plus. It shows internet connection issues and doesn't finish loading the various services. I see the "loading circle going around. Sometimes I get a message saying that the service is having trouble loading my content and to check the internet connection.
Read more
Reply
  • Like
Reactions: charlesrshell
Almighty1
Almighty1
mheisen said:
I'm on H713 on the Hopper and P15403 on the Hopper Plus. It shows internet connection issues and doesn't finish loading the various services. I see the "loading circle going around. Sometimes I get a message saying that the service is having trouble loading my content and to check the internet connection.
Click to expand...
Did it ever work correctly before? Hard to say what the problem is. Usually for streaming, it will show the Dish logo with lines sweeping down to show downloading, never seen the circle issue. Did you try a manual reboot, red button reset, power cord unplug/replug to see if it makes a difference.
Read more
Reply
  • Like
Reactions: charlesrshell
S
slow_poke_pete
Almighty1 said:
Did it ever work correctly before? Hard to say what the problem is. Usually for streaming, it will show the Dish logo with lines sweeping down to show downloading, never seen the circle issue. Did you try a manual reboot, red button reset, power cord unplug/replug to see if it makes a difference.
Click to expand...
Might be worth just to ditch the hopper plus. No issues here on h713
Read more
Reply
S
slow_poke_pete
mheisen said:
Over the past few weeks, I have had problems connecting to streaming services (Netflix, HBO et al). When I go to the TV's native Channels, I have no problem. The Dish internet troubleshooter shows I have a good internet connection. I'm wondering whether it's an issue with my internet provider or a problem with the Dish software on the Hopper Plus. Anyone else seeing this?
Click to expand...
Buy a roku and dump the hopper plus you'll be better off. If you have a smart tv you don't need either one. No hopper plus here and no issues!!!
Read more
Reply
TWiT Tech Podcast Network
· posted in TWiT Tech Podcast Network

Meta Muse Privacy Flaw Exposed Sensitive Shared Links #shorts

Time for another AWESOME video from the TWIT Network!


View: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/nKMpQ3UNenY


Direct YouTube Link - Meta Muse Privacy Flaw Exposed Sensitive Shared Links #shorts
TWIT's Website
TWIT Live Feed
Read more
0 Replies · 4 views
Replies Reply Legacy View
TWiT Tech Podcast Network
· posted in TWiT Tech Podcast Network

AI Is Turning Wannabe Hackers Into Cybercriminals #shorts

Time for another AWESOME video from the TWIT Network!


View: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/I_zmwUPcv50


Direct YouTube Link - AI Is Turning Wannabe Hackers Into Cybercriminals #shorts
TWIT's Website
TWIT Live Feed
Read more
0 Replies · 9 views
Replies Reply Legacy View
TWiT Tech Podcast Network
· posted in TWiT Tech Podcast Network

AI in the NYTimes Cooking App

Time for another AWESOME video from the TWIT Network!


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mGXuqH0DqDs


Direct YouTube Link - AI in the NYTimes Cooking App
TWIT's Website
TWIT Live Feed
Read more
0 Replies · 11 views
Replies Reply Legacy View
TWiT Tech Podcast Network
· posted in TWiT Tech Podcast Network

Responses to PHP Flash Alert

Time for another AWESOME video from the TWIT Network!


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=psVDWmJn7e8


Direct YouTube Link - Responses to PHP Flash Alert
TWIT's Website
TWIT Live Feed
Read more
0 Replies · 1 views
Replies Reply Legacy View
TWiT Tech Podcast Network
· posted in TWiT Tech Podcast Network

Apple's Jump Into the Touchscreen Laptop Market

Time for another AWESOME video from the TWIT Network!


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rLJZNojY-Os


Direct YouTube Link - Apple's Jump Into the Touchscreen Laptop Market
TWIT's Website
TWIT Live Feed
Read more
0 Replies · 11 views
Replies Reply Legacy View
Lon.TV
· posted in Lon.TV

Pre-CES Tech Dispatch! 14 Gadgets in 11 Minutes !

Time for another AWESOME video from Lon Seidman of LON.TV!


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pYnl79ronhs


Direct YouTube Link - Pre-CES Tech Dispatch! 14 Gadgets in 11 Minutes !
The Official LON.TV Website
Lon on Facebook
Read more
0 Replies · 11 views
Replies Reply Legacy View
Load More
Top
Back