Agree. Let's examine the goofy claims in WV, OH, and KY.
The Pirates claim a swath of Ohio, all the way to the Columbus DMA. The team also claims all of WV, even the "eastern panhandle" which is an exurb of Washington, gets Washington TV, and follows the Washington teams. A proper claim in Ohio for the Pirates would just be the Rust Belt towns just inside Ohio, like Steubenville or Youngstown. A proper claim in WV would just be the Monongalia valley (Morgantown, Fairmont, and Clarksburg) and the "northern panhandle" (Wheeling and Weirton).
The Reds claims in Ohio are logical. Their claim in WV is really a bit conservative, as they do not claim the Greenbrier valley. Their claim in KY is logical. Most of the populated part of WV is Reds Country. Most all of KY is as well, with the Cards seeping in in the Purchase.
The Guardians (whatever) claims are ludicrous. They mirror the Reds claim in WV, and claim that part of Kentucky that is in the Huntington-Charleston DMA. The proper claim for that team in WV and KY is not one spec of either state. In Ohio, they claim the entire state except the Cincinnati and Dayton DMAs. There are NO Guardians fans in SE Ohio. None. It is Reds Country. I will give them overlap status in Columbus, but nothing south of there.