Okay, here is my situation. Im calling to get a refund on my 2 month purchased DIRECTV HD reciever next week. It has defects and such. Im wondering if I can bargain my way into an awesome deal for a HD DVR to replace it. I will be recieving my $200 HD rebate any day, but I will not cash It (in case they don't want me to for return purposes). Anyone know what I could say to bargain for maybe an even trade-in, or Im willing to pay, hmmm, say, $199 (+ the orignal handling...$234) for an HD DVR. I would love to be able to cash that rebate check, let them keep the money I paid for the HD box (after the rebate=$134) and maybe pay them $100 with my credit card for them to come take the bad HD reciever and put in a HD DVR (Totaling $234). Sound bargain-able? If it does or doesn't PLEASE leave me some ideas for how to handle this, or just any method to getting a HD DVR for the lowest price possible for DIRECTV customers. Thanks.