Just in case anyone is curious, I have completed keeping track of ALL the Center Ice HD games comparing DISH vs. Directv vs. Cable (at least for the regular season). It is as accurate as I can make it and there may be a few errors. I also included the NHL Network in the comparison, as it is included in the package for satellite, although not on cable, but I needed to make a far comparison.
My conclusions:
Directv has the lead of course, since they have MSG-HD (NYI, NYR, NJD & BUF).
Cable flat out sucks!
Directv does have HD feeds of both teams sometimes, although that was not included in the comparison.
Directv lists games that are on the HD channel, but are just the SD feed, which happens quite often with the Kings/Ducks as so few of their games are produced in HD. I did not included them in the count, but noted them on the comparison.
Overall, Direct has about 20% more HD games than Dish.
I'll be keeping track in the playoffs and report back.
And just for those that want to know, I'm keeping track as I have the option before next season to switch. I am happy with DISH and love the DVR, so at this point the 20% more, which is mostly the NY teams, doesn't really sway me.