EXCELLENT article on Nnamdi and the Raiders....
McDonald: Nnamdi Asomugha not worth what Raiders would have had to pay him
By Jerry McDonald
Oakland Tribune
Posted: 01/10/2011 09:19:57 PM PST
Updated: 01/10/2011 09:19:58 PM PST
Bear with me a moment, because I'm about to do something that goes against the grain of every right-minded amateur and professional general manager or football expert.
The incentives that voided the contract of Raiders Pro Bowl cornerback Nnamdi Asomugha make complete sense.
Across the e-mail, blog, Twitter and talk radio landscape, crazy ol' Al Davis has been taken to task, and the Raiders vilified, for being so incompetent as to not realize there was language in Asomugha's contract that could set him free after two years.
On the heels of the team dumping coach Tom Cable, much to the chagrin of a large part of the Raiders' roster, Asomugha will -- after a collective bargaining agreement is reached -- be able to field offers from any team willing to write a big enough check for his services.
The Raiders know all about this, because they wrote the book on writing the check. The three-year deal Asomugha signed after the 2008 season for $45.3 million was met with dismay by 31 other teams because the market had been reset impossibly high.
If you want to know why Darrelle Revis didn't show up to training camp with the Jets this year, look no further than the Raiders' deal with Asomugha.
At the time, the Raiders had both Asomugha and Pro Bowl punter Shane Lechler up for free agency. Asomugha had been franchised for $9.8 million in 2008, and Lechler's contract had expired. The Raiders reeled both in by paying over the going rate. Way over the going rate.
Within Asomugha's deal, unknown until uncovered by ESPN's Adam Schefter on Sunday, were likely-to-be-earned incentives that would automatically void the deal if not met.
One was playing time, and Asomugha played less in 2010 than he did in 2009 -- missing two games -- because of an ankle injury. The others were performance based. If Asomugha had so much as a single interception, a single sack, a single fumble recovery or a single forced fumble, there would have been no void.
In that case, the Raiders would have to decide whether to pay Asomugha $16.8 million or the average of the top five quarterbacks in the NFL, whichever was higher. In a year when Peyton Manning, Tom Brady and Drew Brees are in line for new contracts.
There's a famous "Seinfield" episode about a television pilot about "nothing."
That's Asomugha in a nutshell.
Because he is so good at covering receivers, Asomugha is the loneliest member of the Raiders defense. Quarterbacks simply don't throw in his direction. He didn't give up a single touchdown pass this season.
That's all well and good, but it's a bottom-line business, and the Raiders still gave up 29 touchdown passes and had 12 interceptions this season. If there's a ripple effect from Asomugha's lockdown skills, it's impossible to detect.
Over the past three seasons, Asomugha has played 45 of 48 games. In those three years, the Raiders gave up 65 touchdown passes and Asomugha had two interceptions. The Raiders were 18-30 overall but 2-1 when Asomugha was out of the lineup.
For that, he was paid $38.3 million.
Asomugha is the Raiders' most thoughtful interview, a team leader, a consummate professional and someone who thinks well beyond football in terms of philanthropic interests. His picture could go next to the word "class" in the dictionary.
When Charles Woodson was with the Raiders, he was known for late nights, sleeping during meetings and letting his prodigious athletic skills make up the difference.
Yet in the two years when Woodson was franchised, pocketing $19.3 million for 19 games (he missed 13 because of injury), he was just as ignored as Asomugha by opposing quarterbacks, managing two interceptions, 2½ sacks, 11 passes defensed and three forced fumbles.
But in those 19 games, Woodson had 103 tackles. Asomugha has 93 tackles and one forced fumble in his past 45 games. He played 14 games this season and had 19 tackles. That's three less than Hiram Eugene, two more than Rock Cartwright.
Woodson was a football player. Asomugha is an able tackler, but he's more of a cover guy. He's a specialist in the way that Lechler, Sebastian Janikowski and long-snapper Jon Condo are the highest-paid specialists in the NFL.
Lechler, Seabass and Condo actually have duties with the football far more often than Asomugha.
Even if the Raiders are at least partially at fault for scheme and not putting Asomugha in position to make enough plays, there is zero justification for paying him in the same ballpark as you would pay Brady, Manning and Brees in terms of yearly salary.
So while the Raiders are being criticized for including a contract void for no statistical production on a $16.8 million (or more) option year, I have a question: Why wouldn't they include one?
The Raiders should do whatever they can to bring back Asomugha, but they should weigh that decision against his contributions to the bottom line, how they'll use him and what the market will bear.
If Asomugha chooses to join Revis with the New York Jets for bigger money or what he believes is a better chance at the Super Bowl, so be it.
As brilliant as Asomugha was at covering receivers in Oakland, it didn't begin to cover for weaknesses elsewhere. He was a luxury on a team not yet good enough to afford one.
McDonald: Nnamdi Asomugha not worth what Raiders would have had to pay him - San Jose Mercury News
