YES (DISH) and I have both! Better on big screen, better on all three LCDs and even on this HD computer monitor! Told Wife last night after watching NBATV in HD on DISH and it was listed in the guide as HD on DirecTV, but not, don't know why I still have D* with only a promise things are going to change someday when they have two more satellites up. Lot of supporters out there willing to wait for D* to catch-up with DISH, but tomorrow may never come! Enjoy today! If you want better OTA SD or HD or more HD DISH is the leader. Guess I thought things were going to change must faster @ D* than they have and I have a sizable investment in DirecTV Tivo DVRs. I thought I had the best having both, but really DISH is just plain better! Maybe someday that will change but as of today DISH is far superior.