charper1,
Everyone's entitled to their opinion. When I was able to have Comcast at my last residence, a lot of those networks did air HD content. Sure they also did pillarboxed OR upconverted & stretched content... some more than others - however they still had HD content.
I just don't see the need for 30+ HD PPV's when you can simply download the movies using VOD. Sure a few HD PPV's for special events is great, but over 30 repeating the same movies over and over again? That sounds like a little too much redundancy right there.
I also agree with you that it would be nice to have all of the premiums available in HD. I think there are some HBO's missing. They have most of the Showtimes, and we subscribe to HBO and Showtime, so that's nice.
When your a service provider that has millions of customers, and millions more potential customers... you need to provide a very dynamic, diverse offering with stuff that appeals to everybody. It's the best way to make everyone happy. While the guy next door gets his sports fix in, the guy across the street gets his movie fix in, and the girls down the street get their "reality TV" fix on; everyone is happy. If everyone is happy, that's more money to DirecTV. What can DirecTV do with more money? Invest it in their network, equipment, and software to continually improve for all of their customers. It benefits everyone in the long run. Money for new expanded HD program guides, Money for new satellite launches. Money for new innovative technology. Money for research into better and more efficient compression and delivery algorithms, to improve audio and picture quality. The list goes on.
Cable providers didn't get this for years, but they are now starting to get with the times. The local cable provider in my area is a small one - not in the top 10 MSO list- However they have about 80 HD channels. Not bad for a small mom and pop shop. The only thing that sucks is their software. It's ugly... there's no real features like cover art and "smart search", or internet integration (program DVR from web or phone app). There's no "Multiroom", limited hard drive space, and everything is in MPEG2 (not so efficient when storing programs to the already limited hard drive). If they just fix this one roadblock, then it's no contest. I'll switch. ETF's? eh, who cares.... I'll pay my money to whomever provides the best user experience, with the most robust content choices available. Right now DirecTV has that best user experience. Content choices... OK, but lacking what it COULD be.
Everyone has an opinion of what they want to see (or don't want to see). That's fine, and by no means any personal attack. I respect your opinion, as anyone else who comments on this thread.
I did send them an e-mail, so I feel better about having some kind of voice (at least). Sure I can't move mountains alone (no one can), but at least I got it off my chest.