Social Feed

P
Last reply · posted in C-BAND Satellite Discussion
Dear folks,
I just found this forum, and hope that perhaps anyone here might be able to help me with the following question:

I own a 10 ft Unimesh dish on an AJAK H/H mount, and living in Europe this means that there are many satellites which lack power for a perfect picture on C-Band. In the 80's and 90's this was no problem, with the necessary audio and video band filters even the weakest signals could be viewed, most notably the Intelsat international news feeds on 4166,5 and 4188,5 MHz.

Digital TV made all of this equipment useless. For a long time I left C-Band for what it was and concentrated purely on Ku-Band improvements on other dishes like my Gregorian 120 cm and a noname 190 cm solid prime focus dish on an EGIS dual motor positioner.

A few years ago I wanted to pick up the bobby of C-Band again and purchased something which appeared to be a total desaster: an MSI C/Ku band LNBF for digital use. It was a desaster in more than one way: first of all it never allowed an equally well reception of opposing linearities: one could optimise RHCP reception but then there was no LHCP reception on C-Band possible, one could optimise for vertical Ku Band reception but then no horizontal channels could be seen, not even on the strongest satellites. In addition the indicated noise figure were an illusion: My Gerdiner 25 degree K LNB which was bought in analog times was at least as sensitive as this one which claimed to be 17 K.

What shocked me most was the shabby construction of the scalar rings. Being used to very sturdy and solid Seavey and Chapparal feeds I now got something that looked as if it was made out of a used tuna fish can. Pure rubbish from a quality point of view.

The funny thing was that I kept reading articles in which it was claimed that for digital reception specially made C-Band digital LNB's are needed because of their improved stability. This one experience at least contradicted this.

Now I am faced with the question how to go on. My basic issues are:

1. I receive a numger of C-Band satellites that are right at the brink of reception/non reception. Most of these, BUT NOT ALL, are in circular polarization. I won't use my dish for Ku-Band reception so no need for compromises on that part. I see that there is a Norsat LNB of 15 degrees K that is offered for prices between $50 and $ 80 but buying that one would force me to go on with an analog sat receiver as intermediary in order to adjust the polarization between horiz-RHCP-vert-LHCP.

2. Obviously a specialized C-Band only LNBF of very good quality would be much easier to use because you would only have to move the dish separately but all other functions would be carried out by the sat receiver.

3. However, somehow I can't imagine how to control such a system if it existed because the average digital sat receiver only knows 2 polarities. I am testing an AZ Box Premium HD+ receiver with experimental Enigma 2 software which appears to list separate settings for these 4 polarities but they are not (yet) functional.

4. My questions:

what should I do, which options do exist if I want an optimal sensitivity reception on C-Band? Get the Norsat 8515 LNB and attach it to a simple 20 year old Chapparal C-Band feedhorn using the skewing function of an analog receiver to switch polarities? Or is the stability of an Norsat LNB exaggerated and might one just as well buy a cheaper one?

or is it possible to get a complete C-Band LNBF of excellent quality in terms of reception which can be controlled by a normal sat receiver? I find so far the receivers of Clarke-Tech/MaxDigital to be the best in terms of sensitivity and blind scan results but they don't allow installation of 4 polarities. Funny enough on one satellite only (40 East) a blind scan gave the indication RHCP in spite of the fact that manually one can only select between V and H. I never found an explanation for that anomaly, other circular polarized signals were always indicated as V or H.

I'd be most grateful for any suggestion!
kindest wishes,
Paul.
11 Replies · 2352 views
FaT Air
a specific combination of LNBF and receiver that offer the selection of all 4 polarities.
The only way I see to have it so you can select linear and circular(all 4 polarities) is to have 2 feeds on the dish. One set up for linear and the other for circular. Selected via a diseqc switch and receiver programming. Pendragon's thread may clear it up.
http://www.satelliteguys.us/c-band-...63-c-band-linear-circular-orthomode-feed.html
btw: i think: chap feed = Chapparal
linuxman
4. My questions:

what should I do, which options do exist if I want an optimal sensitivity reception on C-Band? Get the Norsat 8515 LNB and attach it to a simple 20 year old Chapparal C-Band feedhorn using the skewing function of an analog receiver to switch polarities? Or is the stability of an Norsat LNB exaggerated and might one just as well buy a cheaper one?

or is it possible to get a complete C-Band LNBF of excellent quality in terms of reception which can be controlled by a normal sat receiver? I find so far the receivers of Clarke-Tech/MaxDigital to be the best in terms of sensitivity and blind scan results but they don't allow installation of 4 polarities. Funny enough on one satellite only (40 East) a blind scan gave the indication RHCP in spite of the fact that manually one can only select between V and H. I never found an explanation for that anomaly, other circular polarized signals were always indicated as V or H.
I'll try and help answer your questions.

The best method for receiving both H/V and R/L signals with one feed-horn would be a Chaparral C-Band only orthomode with two of the Norsat LNBs that you listed above. The price is reasonable here in the US, but I don't know what they would cost to have them shipped to Europe.

Most modern receivers only have H/V listed in the settings, but if you use those settings, the RHCP will come in on a V setting, and LHCP will come in on the H setting. You might have to adjust the Local Oscillating Frequency setup in the receiver for satellites in Europe, but you should be able to receive all 4 polarities with this setup provided you have the dialectric plate installed. You would also need a 3x4 multi-switch, or a 4x4 multi-switch to combine the polarities into one coax run and a power inserter installed to raise the R/V voltage output to the required 18V. Most modern receivers only output 18V on H/L and 13V on R/V.

The second best alternative is to use a GesosatPro C-2, C-band only LNBF which is a combination feed-horn and LNB built into one unit with dual outputs. You would only need to use one of the outputs for a single receiver. The functionality should be the same, but no multiswitches would be required with this setup. I have had good success with this unit, but if your signals are extremely weak, the Chaparral C-Band only orthomode feed-horn above would be your best option.

Hope that helps you, and if I have made any mistakes, I am sure someone will correct me.
P
The only way I see to have it so you can select linear and circular(all 4 polarities) is to have 2 feeds on the dish. One set up for linear and the other for circular. Selected via a diseqc switch and receiver programming. Pendragon's thread may clear it up.
http://www.satelliteguys.us/c-band-...63-c-band-linear-circular-orthomode-feed.html
btw: i think: chap feed = Chapparal

Hi chap (I thought of it as just another word for guy, haha, now I know better!)

Somehow the idea of 2 feeds doesn't seem like much of an advantage to me. Sure, you resolve the polarity issue that way but then you traded external polarity switching for switching between feedhorns. And in addition it means working with a compromise as in reality there is just one perfect focal point and last but not least you end up with two close but nevertheless different physical positions in case you use a positioner with accurate degree readouts.

That seems a lot of drawbacks, I think using my old Echostar 50 manual tuner for H/V and skew for R/L would be a better option as just using an external skew control makes any further cost and compromises unnecessary that way.

But thanks for the interesting information and link!

Paul.
P
Thanks very much for your advice. Indeed on Ebay this LNB costs 49 dollars ( see Norsat 8515 C-Band DRO LNB **New** 500KHz Stability | eBay ) but only the shipping costs are rather exaggerated I'm afraid. I hope it's the correct LNB, the numbers seem Ok but the picture differs somewhat from one I saw on other places. And strangely enough on the Norsat site I couldn't even find a 15 degree K LNB at all.
The advantage of the second best alternative you mention for me is not just price. When I use a manually adjusted Chapparal feed the biggest problem for me is that when doing a blind scan the receiver often sees a transponder twice due to cross polarization of the dish. Using a single dedicated LNBF like the second option you mentioned makes manual adjustments unnecessary and therefore causes a blind scan to give simple correct results.
But then of course I don't know if the difference is marginal or significant. From my "golden analog days" I remember quite well how on weaker satellites that were especially close to the horizon very precize skewing was of the essence in order to obtain the best possible reception. And although signals have changed from analog to digital, I cannot really imagine that that aspect would have changed along with it. Or am I wrong in this respect?
linuxman
And although signals have changed from analog to digital, I cannot really imagine that that aspect would have changed along with it. Or am I wrong in this respect?
Precise skewing is essential to receiving signal with the most efficiency, but with these new voltage controlled LNBFs, and with the orthomode feeds, skew is set on you True South Satellite, and the polar mount as it swings across the arc adjusts the skew accordingly.

The result is that you get what you get. :)
P
Thanks very much for your advice. Indeed on Ebay this LNB costs 49 dollars ( see Norsat 8515 C-Band DRO LNB **New** 500KHz Stability | eBay ) but only the shipping costs are rather exaggerated I'm afraid.

Well, this guy wants more than $ 33,00 extra just for the fact that sometimes he has to wait in line in the Post Office. Crazy situation, sot of like a shopkeeper charging extra money for the fact that sometimes he has to wait for customers.

Anyhow: is there any of you who know someone selling this LNB for a similar price but with only the REAL shipping costs? my email address is paulvr20@ tele2.nl I'd greatly appreciate your help!
jamieh1
Last reply · posted in DIRECTV Programming Forum
The new curated multiview is now live.
While on many of the sports channels and non sports channels there is a multi view option button. It will pull up a side bar with many different multi view options.
4 Replies · 178 views
K
It's now expanded to a Build Your Own Multiview, currently available to streaming customers with Geminis and Roku, and coming soon to Android TV, Fire TV, Vizio, LG, Apple TV and Tizen.
b4pjoe
It's now expanded to a Build Your Own Multiview, currently available to streaming customers with Geminis and Roku, and coming soon to Android TV, Fire TV, Vizio, LG, Apple TV and Tizen.
But not on the only device they ship out right now which is the Gemini Air.
  • Sad
Reactions: Jimbo
TheRatPatrol
It's now expanded to a Build Your Own Multiview, currently available to streaming customers with Geminis and Roku, and coming soon to Android TV, Fire TV, Vizio, LG, Apple TV and Tizen.
How soon will it be available on Apple TV? Thanks
I WANT MORE
But not on the only device they ship out right now which is the Gemini Air.
It's on my Air's.
"MysteryMan"
Pub Member / Supporter Cutting Edge
Last reply · posted in Computers and Gadgets
I created this thread on the original Edgecutter Cutting Edge Forums site. It's simply a place for those to review the latest software available for those using Windows 10 and Windows 11. To date it has received 112,559 views. I have been asked by staff to continue this thread here.
522 Replies · 47229 views
EarDemon
If it wasn't for what I want, I wouldn't need any of this.

Do I need a collection of handheld radios, scanners and speed enforcement countermeasures? Nope, but I want them. Very little, if any of the software used to interface with these devices is available on Linux.
WhiteBeard
If it wasn't for what I want, I wouldn't need any of this.

Do I need a collection of handheld radios, scanners and speed enforcement countermeasures? Nope, but I want them. Very little, if any of the software used to interface with these devices is available on Linux.
To each there own but I've found that Windows can't do much more than Linux can. Can't have everything. ☹️
  • Haha
Reactions: meStevo
EarDemon
To each there own but I've found that Windows can't do much more than Linux can. Can't have everything. ☹️
For niche use cases, yes I agree. Kali for ethical hacking and security testing, and running a Cacti server for network monitoring are the two things I have experience in. Plus thousands and thousands of other things, but for every day use I just can't see it. The owner of the GMRS repeater that I pay to access is changing the Tx DPL tones tomorrow, while Chirp is available on Linux, the software to program my MXT500 is not.

I run Fedora and Ubuntu in VMWare, honestly I don't care much for the UI of either of them and I don't feel like spending days/weeks to customize the UI to make it look Windows-like when I could just use Windows. The cartoonish dock at the bottom of the screen reminds me of Apple products.
harshness
I don't care much for the UI of either of them and I don't feel like spending days/weeks to customize the UI to make it look Windows-like when I could just use Windows.
What is so fantabulous about the Windows UI? By many accounts, it has been going downhill since Windows 7.

There are Linux desktops that offer Windows or Mac UIs, yet you don't hear much chatter about them outside of questions about when the creators might get sued.
  • Like
Reactions: HipKat
EarDemon
What is so fantabulous about the Windows UI?
Because it's what I prefer. I know I've said this a few times, I use Open Shell to give me the cascading start menu a la WIN 95 and NT4.0. The only reason I went from Windows Vista to 7 back in the day was because of Classic Shell. I cannot stand anything other than the OG start menu from 30+ years ago. I'm using ExplorerPatcher to give me Windows 10 UI elements of the taskbar and right click context menus.

If you could take a look at how I set up Windows 95, you'd find many similarities to how I use 11.
  • Like
Reactions: cp2k
EarDemon
I could probably use that as a starting point, but I don't like the full size icons. If you have to click on each folder that's also a no-go for me, it has to be cascading.

I used to have Peppermint Linux in a VM, that was about as close as I could get to recreating a Windows NT4.0 style of menu structure, but I could never get it to scale properly in VMWare on a 4K display and eventually gave up.

Whatever the boot up time it's fine with me. The longest part of my bootup is the HP SureStart BIOS integrity check. Once that is done, it's only a few more seconds. I haven't done this reg tweak yet since the reformat, but I switched the bootup animation to the Windows 10 style spinning circle of dots, and it's two and a half rotations. I can live with that.
harshness
Because it's what I prefer.
I hope you don't believe that makes it wonderful (especially when you're using workarounds for Microsoft's malfeasance).

I use LibreOffice as opposed to Microsoft office (even in Windows) because it's UI is like the Office of old, so I'm putting my money where my mouth is (in a manner of speaking). The ribbon was one of the worst ideas to come out Redmond.
HipKat
I could probably use that as a starting point, but I don't like the full size icons. If you have to click on each folder that's also a no-go for me, it has to be cascading.

I used to have Peppermint Linux in a VM, that was about as close as I could get to recreating a Windows NT4.0 style of menu structure, but I could never get it to scale properly in VMWare on a 4K display and eventually gave up.

Whatever the boot up time it's fine with me. The longest part of my bootup is the HP SureStart BIOS integrity check. Once that is done, it's only a few more seconds. I haven't done this reg tweak yet since the reformat, but I switched the bootup animation to the Windows 10 style spinning circle of dots, and it's two and a half rotations. I can live with that.
I used to pin the C: drive to the Win Taskbar and it would open in cascading style
Former member 209992
Last reply · posted in SatelliteGuys Support Center
For some reason, the satelliteguys.us site is loading a lot slower than usual on both Chrome on my Asus laptop and Safari on my iPhone.
I'm also seeing longer appearances of the blue bar at the top and the "3 blue bars" loading symbol.
Is anyone else also having the same problem? Thanks in advance.
528 Replies · 17953 views
  • Like
Reactions: charlesrshell
Scott Greczkowski
Remember folks... just like DNS... its always Foxbat. :D
Foxbat
Remember folks... just like DNS... its always Foxbat. :D
WTF… …What the Foxbat!😱
S
zipping right along here
S
WTF… …What the Foxbat!😱
wow what a kick in the balls!!! the wife blames you when things don't work now scott's blaming you :biggrin
Foxbat
wow what a kick in the balls!!! the wife blames you when things don't work now scott's blaming you :biggrin
I know. Here's what Scott has in store for me if I get out of line:
IMG_1990.webp
IMG_1989.webp
S
I know. Here's what Scott has in store for me if I get out of line:
OMG to freaking funny :biggrin
cpdretired
Supporting Founder
Last reply · posted in DISH Network Support Forum
Several Dish offers showed up today in my account. Once you choose one the rest are removed. Offers were Showtime, Starz, AMC and others.
33 Replies · 1590 views
  • Like
Reactions: ewindowman and LQQK
B
Just checked my account and it shows mgm+ at 8.00 per month, but that has red line drawn thru it and shows 0.00 per month. But it doesn't say how long this lasts,...... 1 month, 3 months, forever. I called customer service to get an answer, and they said nothing like that exists. Should I add the offer or not? Already paying them too much, but want to take advantage of something free.
ewindowman
Lots of offers on the hopper account app . On the website there are only a few.
Almighty1
Lots of offers on the hopper account app . On the website there are only a few.
Never had time to use the Hopper 3 account app yet. I also have a Hopper Plus so it's not the same as the Hopper 3 standalone. Will try it when I have more time, need to beat the taxes extension filing deadline first as I am still working on entering the data into the tax software.
Almighty1
This is what I see when it comes to offers on My Account on the Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus and dish.com:

AMC+ 50% off for 3 months (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)
AMC+ Free for 3 months (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus and dish.com)
AMC+ 1 month free (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)

Cine y Entretenimie 50% off for 3 months

DOGTV 1 month free (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)

DISH Movie Pack 50% off for 6 months (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus and dish.com)

DOGTV 50% off for 6 months (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)
DOGTV 1 month free (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)

Gallery First Month Free (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)

Heartland Pack 50% off for 6 months (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus and dish.com)

Mexico y Mas 50% off for 3 months (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)

MGM+ $0.00/Month not saying how long (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)

Multi-Sport Pack 50% off for 6 months (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)

Netflix Standard with Ads, $7.99/month credit toward Netflix Standard with Ads ($.99) month with 24 month DISH commitment
(Only on My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)

Outdoor Pack 50% off for 6 months (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)

Paramount+ with SHOWTIME 50% off for three months (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus and dish.com)
Paramount+ with SHOWTIME 2 months free (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)

Playboy TV 50% off for 6 months (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)

Republica Dominicana 50% off for 3 months (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)

STARZ 50% off for 3 months (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)
STARZ $1.99/month for 2 months (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus and dish.com)

Sudamerica y Mas 50% off for 3 months (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)

UP Faith & Family 1 month free (My Account Hopper 3 with Hopper Plus)
S
Just checked my account and it shows mgm+ at 8.00 per month, but that has red line drawn thru it and shows 0.00 per month. But it doesn't say how long this lasts,...... 1 month, 3 months, forever. I called customer service to get an answer, and they said nothing like that exists. Should I add the offer or not? Already paying them too much, but want to take advantage of something free.
look again mine says free for 1 month
Almighty1
look again mine says free for 1 month
Not for me, mines has no mention of how long aka the offer period and the Terms and conditions the $0.00 is good for. All I see is one can lose $5.00 if you decide to remove it before day 31 after you add it to the account.

1792131071109.webp
  • Wow
Reactions: slow_poke_pete
S
Not for me, mines has no mention of how long aka the offer period and the Terms and conditions the $0.00 is good for. All I see is one can lose $5.00 if you decide to remove it before day 31 after you add it to the account.

View attachment 194817
wonder why it says that
Scott Greczkowski
Staff member HERE TO HELP YOU! Cutting Edge
Last reply · posted in The Chit Chat Club
Sometimes a thread gets so many posts in it that is can cause issues for the server so that why today we introduce The Song Name Game Part 3!

So let the game continue!

The last song was added by Bobby who posted...

One Meat Ball - Andrews Sisters

CONTINUE ON AND HAVE FUN! WELCOME HOME TO SATELLITEGUYS.US!

Here are the original rules for the game as posted by WebbyDude back in 2006. http://www.satelliteguys.us/threads/68645-Song-Name-Game

Just name a song title and the band who performed it. The next person does the same thing, but needs to list a song title or band name which includes a word from the previous entry. Pick songs from any genre.

Example:

Long Live Rock and Roll -- Rainbow

Rainbow in the Dark -- Dio

Another example:

Ride the Lightning -- Metallica

Lightning Strikes -- Ozzy Osbourne


Get it?


An additional note: we all know that song titles, sometimes, use profane words. Because this is a family friendly website it is advised that you clean up that title up a bit. This is accomplished by using something like sh!t instead of the real word. Thanks....
68496 Replies · 2670684 views
  • Like
Reactions: c-spand
sdfntx
White Noise - Jessie Baylin
  • Like
Reactions: Bobby
dishstaller
White Rabbit - Jefferson Airplane
  • Like
Reactions: ClarkGable
long_time_Dish
White Sun - The Doobie Brothers
H
White Room-Cream
  • Like
Reactions: ClarkGable
ClarkGable
White Wedding - Billy Idol
jannah
Last reply · posted in DISH Network Support Forum
Help, I'm a little confjused on the activation process.
I purchased the Joey 4 from Solid Signal and shipping box has Call 866 726-4282 to Avtivate new Receiver. That number is Solid Signals number.
I googled and that search said call Dish to activate. I assume that is correct unless this requires a 2 step process.
Please let me know.
Thanks
6 Replies · 212 views
jannah
All good called Dish and new Joey 4 is activated and working.
Old Joey 2 deactivated and no need to return. 🙂
S
All good called Dish and new Joey 4 is activated and working.
Old Joey 2 deactivated and no need to return. 🙂
i bought mine straight from dish as it was only $ 100.00 bucks!!! had the protection plan they came out removed and deactivated the 4k joey and activated and installed the joey 4.
zcrayfish
Solid signal has provided the wrong number on their website to activate Dish boxes for years now.
  • Like
Reactions: charlesrshell
Nominal
I don't know if things are different with Dish but when I first rejoined DirecTV a few years ago Solid Signal was able to create my account and activate the equipment I got from them on a self-install without a truck roll.
S
Solid signal has provided the wrong number on their website to activate Dish boxes for years now.
1-800-333-3474. billing or tech support should be able to do it!!!
S
Help, I'm a little confjused on the activation process.
I purchased the Joey 4 from Solid Signal and shipping box has Call 866 726-4282 to Avtivate new Receiver. That number is Solid Signals number.
I googled and that search said call Dish to activate. I assume that is correct unless this requires a 2 step process.
Please let me know.
Thanks
just call dish and iggy the number from solid signal!!
Foxbat
Supporting Founder Pub Member / Supporter Lifetime Supporter
Last reply · posted in Internet Television (IPTV) Discussion Forum
Apple has finally released their Apple TV 4K with built-in Siri and a microphone so it can respond to your queries even if you don't have the remote. It also increases in price, to $299. I had been planning on updating my current Apple TV 4K streamers, but that's $600 for the two of them, and that's a pass at this point.

At $299, it had better come with 256 GB of Storage, Gigabit (or better) Ethernet, the latest HDMI tech and standards, and one year of free Apple One. But it probably won't…
14 Replies · 196 views
Ronnie-
Meh. The 4Ks I have will do everything that these do that I need them to do.


Which that's most tech these days for anything released the last four to five years.


It's honestly a testament to how good the previous gen Apple TVs were and are.
navychop
It's honestly a testament to how good the previous gen Apple TVs were and are.

Don't tell them that. They'll adopt planned obsolescence.
Foxbat
The only thing I can see that is compelling is the AV1 decoding done in the A19's hardware instead of the current ATV4K's processor.
navychop
Outside of gaming, would Joe Sixpack notice any difference?
KAB
KAB
Outside of gaming, would Joe Sixpack notice any difference?
Not a bit. IMO, Apple's are slow to boot up. Time is about the same with 1st gen and 3rd. Roku runs rings around them in that department. I only reason I stuck, is the Apple infrastructure, which has it's definite advantages. But $300 is a deal breaker. Later, Apple!
S
Don't tell them that. They'll adopt planned obsolescence.
they all do that anyways.. ever notice your cell phone slows down when you come up for an upgrade.. :what. apple's been making money off of software and not hardware for a while
Ramy
Supporting Founder
Last reply · posted in The Sports Section
Really excited for this season with Kentucky having a new coach and some really exciting recruits. Probably won't last long, but here's hoping this season is great.
141 Replies · 1369 views
  • Haha
Reactions: Mike0616
Y
24 team playoff seems to be real close.

Are we really that far from a 64-team tournament?

The benefit of the 24 team playoff:
  • All the cartel teams that cartels want in playoff are in playoff
    • Independent of record too! Bonus.
  • MONEY!!!!! for the cartels.
  • I'm out of ideas.
Cons
  • Regular season really doesn't matter now other than the rivalry games
    • Top cartel teams can lose three games and still make the playoff
  • Going to start resting players?
    • The playoff is going to be *checks notes* several games!
    • Resting players could make games dumb.
    • Maybe even restrict NIL players from games played.
  • How much are streaming sub costs going up a month to pay for this?!
AZ.
AZ.
24 team playoff seems to be real close.

Are we really that far from a 64-team tournament?

The benefit of the 24 team playoff:
  • All the cartel teams that cartels want in playoff are in playoff
    • Independent of record too! Bonus.
  • MONEY!!!!! for the cartels.
  • I'm out of ideas.
Cons
  • Regular season really doesn't matter now other than the rivalry games
    • Top cartel teams can lose three games and still make the playoff
  • Going to start resting players?
    • The playoff is going to be *checks notes* several games!
    • Resting players could make games dumb.
    • Maybe even restrict NIL players from games played.
  • How much are streaming sub costs going up a month to pay for this?!
One of the pro's I see is in a year with so many undefeated teams they have a good chance of an opening. Few years back you had lower divisions that didnt get a shot. I love collage football and I have no problem with that addition.

We are in what week 5 now? Been two real good ranked games to watch.....Other than that top 25 teams are playing nothing.
Jimbo
One of the pro's I see is in a year with so many undefeated teams they have a good chance of an opening. Few years back you had lower divisions that didnt get a shot. I love collage football and I have no problem with that addition.

We are in what week 5 now? Been two real good ranked games to watch.....Other than that top 25 teams are playing nothing.
There are 68 Power 4 teams, so eventually they will get there I wouldn't imagine ...
AZ.
AZ.
There are 68 Power 4 teams, so eventually they will get there I wouldn't imagine ...
Far from it but you know that....You dont like the larger playoff.....Its ok.....
Jimbo
Far from it but you know that....You dont like the larger playoff.....Its ok.....
Oh, I Hate the idea ...

It would be different if it was a game that you could play 2 or games each week, but when you only play 1 game a week, the larger playoff is Not a good thing ...

The season has how many games now, is it 14 ... then you want to play another 5 (with more to come) against Top 12 (eventually 24 teams) ... remember, the 5 games in the playoffs will be the hardest games all year and back to back.

For example, IF Ohio State should win it all this year ... they play 5 teams in the Top 25, plus they would play 5 more to win it all, depending on how the ranking shake out and if Bye weeks are given.

Thats 10 Ranked teams ... in one year ...
I don't see that happening very often ...
Edit, Bama plays 4, Georgia plays 3, But Ole Miss plays 5 (didn't expect to see that)

That said, I don't see the Buckeyes winning it all this year.
  • Like
Reactions: AZ.
AZ.
AZ.
Oh, I Hate the idea ...

It would be different if it was a game that you could play 2 or games each week, but when you only play 1 game a week, the larger playoff is Not a good thing ...

The season has how many games now, is it 14 ... then you want to play another 5 (with more to come) against Top 12 (eventually 24 teams) ... remember, the 5 games in the playoffs will be the hardest games all year and back to back.

For example, IF Ohio State should win it all this year ... they play 5 teams in the Top 25, plus they would play 5 more to win it all, depending on how the ranking shake out and if Bye weeks are given.

Thats 10 Ranked teams ... in one year ...
I don't see that happening very often ...

That said, I don't see the Buckeyes winning it all this year.
Yes anyone here knows you 100%....Astros failed no posting...Ohio state loses we hear it.....Its ok....Its called an opinion....I have one so do you.....Problem is?
Jimbo
Yes anyone here knows you 100%....Astros failed no posting...Ohio state loses we hear it.....Its ok....Its called an opinion....I have one so do you.....Problem is?
Seeing theres very little activity in the MLB threads, it wouldn't matter if I posted that the Astros didn't make the Playoffs ...

Theres more NFL info in the Pub section than in the Sports/NFL thread.
  • Like
Reactions: AZ.
Jimbo
IF they go to 24 teams, and it looks like they will soon ....
Do we Really want Teams with 3 and 4 losses in the Playoffs ?
Is a 3-4 Loss team one thats able to win 4-5 more games against Top teams ?