I have been experimenting for the last 20 years with dishes from 4 to 10 feet, LNBs, and receivers.
Some things to note when trying to receive DVB S2/8PSK:
1. The satellite footprint for your area and the signal strength. Intelsats have a weaker signal strength for US. Locations.
2. The polarity of the satellite transponder. Satellites with circular reception require a dedicated LNB for reception. I have used a 6ft dish with a DMX 741U combo C/KU with Teflon insert to get 40.5W that consisted off all circular polarities and could not get any S2. I switched over to a Chaparral LNB and was able to get all S2 using the same size dish. Hence it is not just a matter of dish size but you can use a smaller dish with a higher quality LNB.
3. Receiver sensitivity. Some receivers I used like Satcruiser, AZBOX, Amiko A3 have a sensitive tuner with minimal heating to the S2 Tuner card and allow stable reception with a smaller dish.
4. Alignment of your system, motorized or non motorized. Obviously a larger dish is more forgiving with a signal than a smaller dish
So what I found out that using a 6 footer, high quality LNB, and a sensitive receiver I was able to get 98% S2, 8PSK. From roughly 22W to 136W. Newer receivers contributed enormously with faster processors and better bugless freezing.
Smaller than 6 feet was "hit or miss".
An 8 footer would be better if your LNB/receiver was not cutting edge