I would have the cost for the first Hopper as well, of $99. So it would be cheaper to go with DIRECTV and get the additional discount on the second year.
HMC $99 + 3 HD Receivers free, and one HD receiver at $99 = $198
OK, I was losing track of the message flow - confused you with jdsabin1, looked like he was a current Dish customer.
For five locations it's still a wash if at AT200 or better for new business:
Dish New = $199 second hopper + Free first hopper + 3 Joeys = $199 (+ another $99 for first Hopper if less than AT200).
Dish Upgrade = $100 First Hopper + $100 Second Hopper + 3 Joeys = $200
As far as the 2nd year promos, just have to run the numbers for your situation and see what works.
One warning on the 2nd year Directv promos - they supposedly are going away the 15th. You may want to go ahead and pull the trigger if you want to go that route. Disclaimer to the warning - its only based on what I've seen here.