That's what I thought. When I chatted with Dish they said it was free. When I asked why it said "Subscribe" and not just "Watch" they said that meant I couldn't watch it immediately, I had to download it first. Thanks for the quick replies!
Weird. There was a free trial of Epix last week and I recorded Hugo. After I watched it all, and it cut off the end, I noticed the Hopper said 2 hours 6 minutes, but it only recorded 1 hour 46 minutes. That's why I was looking for it in On-Demand.