If they offered popular HD channels as well it might have a real chance. For people that just have OTA and would like a few other channels that they would normally have to buy a large package subscription to get it might be worth getting. For example, right now I have a PAL DVR to get all OTA channels in my area, if I could get ESPN HD, ESPN2 HD, SPEED HD, FOOD HD & Lifetime HD for a price of say $1.99 per channel it would be worth it to me. As it stands now it really isn't worth it for most people.