In 7 full seasons with the Indians, C.C. had an ERA over 4.00 four times, and never had an ERA below 3.21 (last season).
In 4 1/2 full seasons with the Indians, Bartolo Colon had an ERA over 4.00 once (4.09 in 2001), and he pitched in more of the "steroids" era of offense.
Colon had an ERA of...