Spent some time outside (great weather today, going back out after this post) trying to determine where the interference is coming from.
Using a variety of objects (metal snow shovel, plexiglass, wooden board, myself!) I was able to determine it is not earth based either from underneath, either side, back, or front, when checking below where satellite signals hit the dish.
When attempting to block out signals to the east of AMC4, it did appear to have some effect, however, due to the width of the beams that hit the dish as opposed to the focused signals at the LNB, it was not possible to duplicate the excellent results achieved by the blinder.
Back out to the lawn chair, and a well deserved rest!