2021-22 NCAA Football Thread

[Jimbo]

Rules committee deciding on changes.

NCAA proposes review of targeting, fake injuries

A proposed rule change would allow conferences to appeal second-half targeting fouls in order to avoid the penalty of sitting out the first half of the next game, the NCAA Football Rules Committee announced on Friday.

www.espn.com

 

[Don in CT]

Rules committee deciding on changes.

NCAA proposes review of targeting, fake injuries

A proposed rule change would allow conferences to appeal second-half targeting fouls in order to avoid the penalty of sitting out the first half of the next game, the NCAA Football Rules Committee announced on Friday.

www.espn.com

How about fix overtime.

 

[SamCdbs]

College overtime isn't broken.

 

[Don in CT]

College overtime isn't broken.

They have the worst overtime in all of sports.

 

[AZ.]

They have the worst overtime in all of sports.

worse than the NFL?...worse than MLB last 2 years?

 

[Don in CT]

worse than the NFL?...worse than MLB last 2 years?

I'd take the NFL over college. In a perfect world. Each team gets two positions then sudden death. The college ball on the 20 and everyone gets a participation trophy is stupid.

 

[Jimbo]

I'd take the NFL over college. In a perfect world. Each team gets two positions then sudden death. The college ball on the 20 and everyone gets a participation trophy is stupid.

Where do you get a participation trophy in College OT ?

The "You have to go for 2 after the 2nd score" needs to go.

I don't even remember who has it, I think its college now, thats just BAD.

I like the College version till they added the having to go for 2 part.
I would do away with the having to go for 2 and move the ball back to the 40 yard line or maybe even the 50 yard line and start from there, this way the whole game gets played. You can score or Try a FG or have to PUNT.
At least the game is still in play.

 

[Jimbo]

worse than the NFL?...worse than MLB last 2 years?

Actually, if you think about it, the MLB is really bad, but I think that it is very similar .... Your basically setting up the teams to score in both instances.

 

[Don in CT]

Don’t call it a third fifth overtime. There is no clock, they are only playing downs. Play a normal overtime. They make it sound like it’s an epic 6 OT game when it isn’t.

 

[SamCdbs]

A "normal" OT is usually determined by who wins the coin toss and kicks a FG. The college OT resolves the game quickly and in an exciting and legitimate fashion.

 

[Jimbo]

A "normal" OT is usually determined by who wins the coin toss and kicks a FG. The college OT resolves the game quickly and in an exciting and legitimate fashion.

I don't want anything to do with the "Go for 2 "rule after the 1st round.

 

[Derwin0]

They have the worst overtime in all of sports.

I disagree, I'd have to say the NFL's is worse.

I do think college needs to go back to how it was before they turned the 3rd (and future) possessions into 2 yard plays.

 

[Don in CT]

I disagree, I'd have to say the NFL's is worse.

I do think college needs to go back to how it was before they turned the 3rd (and future) possessions into 2 yard plays.

I think the NFL makes a change this year.

 

[Derwin0]

I think the NFL makes a change this year.

Doubtful, there have been complaints for many years over OT games ending before the other team has a chance to touch the field, yet nothing ever changes.

And since teams that win the coin toss only win 52.8% of the time (just over half), the league has never seen a reason to change things.

 

[Don in CT]

NFL Competition Committee to discuss possible changes to overtime rules

Rich McKay, chairman of the NFL's Competition Committee, said Sunday there is no question proposed changes to overtime will be brought up, NFL Network's Judy Battista reported.

www.nfl.com

 

[Derwin0]

NFL Competition Committee to discuss possible changes to overtime rules

Rich McKay, chairman of the NFL's Competition Committee, said Sunday there is no question proposed changes to overtime will be brought up, NFL Network's Judy Battista reported.

www.nfl.com

Discussing things is a far cry from actually changing them. Yeah, they'll talk about them (again), and decide to keep them as is (again).

Like I said, the Bills/Chiefs game was far from the 1st game to be decided before the coin toss loser took the field.

The last OT rules change was back in 2010, where they made it that the coin toss winner making a field goal did not end the game (allowing the other team a single possession to tie or win), still allowing an opening touchdown to win.

 

[Don in CT]

Discussing things is a far cry from actually changing them. Yeah, they'll talk about them (again), and decide to keep them as is (again).

Like I said, the Bills/Chiefs game was far from the 1st game to be decided before the coin toss loser took the field.

If enough owners complain they will change it. Make it 2 possessions in overtime then sudden death.

 

[Derwin0]

If enough owners complain they will change it. Make it 2 possessions in overtime then sudden death.

Yeah, if enough owners complain. Not enough are, are they are happy with how it is (with half the coin toss winners winning and half losing).

 

[Don in CT]

Yeah, if enough owners complain. Not enough are, are they are happy with how it is (with half the coin toss winners winning and half losing).

The problem is not enough games go to overtime. It's only an issue in the playoffs.

 

[Derwin0]

The problem is not enough games go to overtime. It's only an issue in the playoffs.

It's always been an issue, and never changed. The Falcons lost the Super Bowl to the Patriots in OT on the Patriots opening drive, yet the rules remained as is.

Owners are quite happy to leave things as they are.