37686
I went to antenna web.org I am located behind a hill.
I read earlier after I posted that this is just a UHF antenna. According to antennaweb I am just about 12 miles from the antennas. There is just a hill inbetween us.
On another note I bought a GE 22 DB booster and just hooked it up and I can get all channels VHF and UHF with my current antenna in 1 position plus an additional UHF channel. Plus it is also cloudy. I was leary about paying $37 for a antenna booster made by GE however if it does not do the job I will take it back. So far so good.
The way I see it you have a couple of different problems. First of all you have signals coming in three different directions. Two different directions if you don't care about the independent WLFG on channel 49. The second thing I see is that after the transition in 2009 you will have two channels (WCYB ch.5 and WJHL ch.11) will be moving to VHF. And the third problem is "the hill". You have a challenging task ahead of you.
Here is what I would do. Use the UHF only antenna and point it at WEMT your FOX affiliate. That channel is coming in from a different direction from the rest and will stay on UHF post transition. Get another antenna that will do VHF/UHF and point it at the rest. Keep in mind that you will have a channel on VHF low (ch. 5) so you cannot take advantage of the smaller VHF-Hi/UHF antennas. Something like a Winegard HD-7010 should work nicely. Combine the signals from the two antennas and send it down one coax. Get both antennas as high as possible. Especially one pointing at "the hill".
Let us know how it works out for you.
See attached pictures pre and post transition from tvfool.com for your zip.