She has ears! You or I could go be a judge and say "you sounded good," or "too nasal," or "that was horrible."What does she know about singing? GMAFB
I'm not a singer, but I can tell you Miley Cyrus can't sing for diddly.
True, but not my point. All the other judges are, in some fashion, professionals in the music industry...making them generally more qualified than either you or I to determine who has genuine musical talent and who doesn't. Where/how does that qualification apply to Ellen? Not at all...
Didn't watch Idol before, still won't watch it.