That Reddit report is encouraging — a Match Content switch would fix the one thing that annoyed me most about the older Gemini boxes, HDR being forced on for everything.
If anyone gets the new box, the test I'd run before judging it is:
- Turn on the Match Content switch in the Display menu, then watch a known HDR title and a regular SDR channel back to back. With matching on, the SDR channel should look normal instead of washed out or overly bright, and the HDR title should still switch the TV into HDR.
- Check what the TV itself reports for each one — most TVs show the picture mode or an HDR badge when you press Info or Display — so you're not just guessing from how it looks.
- If your TV handles HDR poorly, as Tom mentioned, leave HDR off on the Gemini entirely. A good SDR picture beats a bad HDR picture every time.
- After changing the HDR or Match Content setting, reboot the box once before testing. On the older boxes those display changes sometimes didn't stick properly until a restart.
If auto-detect is actually working on this one, that's a real improvement over the Osprey and the first Gemini.