Like I said, this is a circular conversation. You don't accept my points, and I don't accept yours. We are going to keep saying the same things and keep thinking the other is wrong, for our own reasons. We've gone how many posts on this, and given you an example that you shut down, however I also said there are many ways they can. Neither of us have any inside info to what Dish can do, we only have the claims actually made by the channel owner, under oath. Multiple times they have made that, everytime they sue Dish, TiVo and anyone else.