Ha! It's definitely a first world problem. The list of games I have a strong urge to play for the first time, finish, or replay is probably long enough that I could never buy another game and still not run out of things to play.
My short list includes Fallout 4, The Division, Gears 3, The Witness, Dying Light, Dark Souls, Bloodborne, Far Cry 4, Uncharted 2, Uncharted 3, Dead Space, and the Mass Effect series. That is just scratching the surface and it's not including the multiplayer games I continue to pour hours into like Rocket League, Heroes of the Storm, and Black Ops 3.
Edit: I also got the email from Gamefly that MLB the Show 16 shipped yesterday and Quantum Break should be coming next week.