Which elliptical for AMC4?

[hdtv_md]

I'm trying to consolidate a couple of dishes into a larger elliptical and have narrowed it down to DTV World Direct (36" x 24") and the Gainmaster 75E (36" x 27"). Which dish would let me grab AMC4 reliably?

I currently have a Winegard 30" that is covering AMC4.

Anyone have a working setup?

TIA!

 

[Mr Tony]

both will work fine