Who will be "retired" 1st: Poll......Looks like Weis is the winner!!!

Who will be gone first?

  • Charlie @ ND

    Votes: 28 71.8%
  • Rich @ Michigan

    Votes: 8 20.5%
  • Bowden @ FSU

    Votes: 3 7.7%

  • Total voters
    39
Is Miles a Michigan man ?

IF so, there's your answer.....
If he's not a M man then I would say, there's no way he's going there, but then again, he considered it a few years back.

He went to school there, played for Schembechler there, was an assistant there for two separate stints, so I would say he IS a Michigan guy. Will he take that program when he seems to be doing well at LSU and there is not a of financial incentives that he can get over LSU? (Miles is making $3.751 million at LSU while RR is making $2.521 million at UM.) Unless he really wants a major challenge, I think the answer is a resounding no.

Interesting side note: When RR was sued by WVU for breach of contract, UM decided to pay $2.5 million of his buyout for him. :( Dumb decision, IMO.
 
He went to school there, played for Schembechler there, was an assistant there for two separate stints, so I would say he IS a Michigan guy. Will he take that program when he seems to be doing well at LSU and there is not a of financial incentives that he can get over LSU? (Miles is making $3.751 million at LSU while RR is making $2.521 million at UM.) Unless he really wants a major challenge, I think the answer is a resounding no.

Interesting side note: When RR was sued by WVU for breach of contract, UM decided to pay $2.5 million of his buyout for him. :( Dumb decision, IMO.
To add to your resounding "no" is the fact that Miles would be taking over a program that has been decimated by RR. Even if Michigan were able to to sign Miles (very, very remote possibility), Miles is probably looking at a couple of 8-6 seasons before he can recover the program.

To be honest, the "one" hope of Miles jumping ship is the fact he would have full-control of the Football Program and his arrival at Michigan would be hailed as the second coming of Christ (thaks RR!). Additionally, he would be offered a 5-year contract and be well-compensated. Michigan is paying a gazillion dollars in stadium renovations (luxury boxes, etc.) and the University simply will not tolerate empty seats and another losing season.

I predict that both RR and AD Martin are gone after this season. BTW, here is another black-eye for the Michigan Football program:

Michigan Athletic Director Bill Martin accused of pushing, grabbing student employees

Retiring Michigan Athletic Director Bill Martin admitted Monday he mishandled a situation with an employee who alleged Martin grabbed him at Michigan Stadium after the Delaware State game this fall.

Another security employee also reported to police that Martin pushed her after the Notre Dame game a month earlier, but Martin said in a letter he didn't recall that incident.

The latest incident occurred just three days before Martin abruptly announced his retirement on Oct. 21. That same day, a police investigator alerted Martin of the police investigation, a police report said.

Full Story
 
Martin will be a real loss to UM, it sure looks like. NOT! Pushing two students around, one of them a female, sure shows his lack of character. Looks like he is out of there, at least.

As for Miles, I don't know why he would want to take over a program that has been rather substantially downgraded (read: wrecked.) IMO, he will only take the job IF he is really wanting a challenge, not the money, prestige, etc.; as he pretty well has that at LSU.
 
rant on

Looks like even the blowhards at ESPN have written off Fat Chollie hanging around at ND next season. After losing to UConn in spite of the best efforts of the officials, ND now has a 6-5 record. Even before losing to Stanford next weekend, he now has the lowest winning at home percentage of any coach since 1975. Any of them. Coupled with the fact that he has went 3-9, 6-6 the last 2 years and will go 6-6 for this season, it appears that his tenure is about over. Instead of the "fat lady singing" it may be more appropriate to say that the "fat man has cried the blues" and the misery of ND fans may soon be over.

As to RR at UM, his 8-16 tenure has to be getting to the fans at UM. Carr was canned with a winning percentage of better than 75% and I don't think 33% was quite what they had in mind for his replacement. In view of the NCAA's inquiry into possible violations of the "20 hour rule" by RR and his cronies, this may be the out for the UM administration in that they can use it as an excuse to send him on his way.

As for Coach Bowden, his team will now finish no worse than 6-6 for the season (anticipating the likely shellacking that FSU will take from UF next weekend) , but only 4-4 in the ACC. With the growing dissatisfaction emanating from all sides (including Chairman of the university board of trustee's Jim Smith), it may well be time for Coach Bowden to call an end to the suffering an resign before he is forced out. See:
Chair of board of trustees calls for Bobby Bowden's head at Florida State - ESPN

None of the 3 have been forced to "retire" as of today, but looks like all 3 are very good candidates for it withing the next two weeks. RR's season is over, while FC and BB still each have one game left on their schedules.

/rant off
 
Is Miles a Michigan man ?

IF so, there's your answer.....
If he's not a M man then I would say, there's no way he's going there, but then again, he considered it a few years back.

What exactly is a "MICHIGAN" man? Schembechler came from Woody's program. You know - "that evil school from the South". Anybody who can come in here and win is a "MICHIGAN" man.
 
Martin will be a real loss to UM, it sure looks like. NOT! Pushing two students around, one of them a female, sure shows his lack of character. Looks like he is out of there, at least.

As for Miles, I don't know why he would want to take over a program that has been rather substantially downgraded (read: wrecked.) IMO, he will only take the job IF he is really wanting a challenge, not the money, prestige, etc.; as he pretty well has that at LSU.

Chances are, he's got plenty of money.
IF he decided he wanted to take over the M job and was successful as expected, he would restore the image in AA and potentially beat the hated team down south (OSU) .

He would be considered a Saint ...
 
What exactly is a "MICHIGAN" man? Schembechler came from Woody's program. You know - "that evil school from the South". Anybody who can come in here and win is a "MICHIGAN" man.

Good point, but we are not going to let you have anymore of OUR guys.
I would rather have Dantonio in Columbus vs East Lansing. (MSU)
 
Fat Chollie in 2004: "You are what you are, folks, and right now you're a 6-5 football team. And guess what? That's just not good enough. That's not good enough for you, and it's certainly not going to be good enough for me."

Fat Chollie in 2009: "Charlie Weis says he can't envision a scenario where he would resign."

Would an estimated $18 million buyout have anything to do with it? :D

Charlie Weis says indeed, 6-5 not good enough for Notre Dame Fighting Irish - ESPN
 
Chances are, he's got plenty of money.
IF he decided he wanted to take over the M job and was successful as expected, he would restore the image in AA and potentially beat the hated team down south (OSU) .

He would be considered a Saint ...

That is what I thought, that there would have to be a reason outside of $$$ for him to change. If he can undo the damage that RR has done to the program, you are right, he may well be deemed a saint in AA. :) First, I think he may have to at least starting winning a game every once in a while with the "evil team of the south".
 
Is Fat Chollie is the winner?

"Notre Dame's loss to Connecticut on Saturday did nothing to quiet the rumor mill surrounding the future of coach Charlie Weis. A change in an upcoming recruiting trip for the embattled coach won't help either.

Following the Irish's regular-season finale loss to Southern California last year, Weis stayed on the West Coast for a recruiting trip. He won't have that chance following Saturday's game against Stanford."


Notre Dame athletics director Jack Swarbrick: No West Coast recruiting trip for Charlie Weis - ESPN
 
Fat Chollie in 2004: "You are what you are, folks, and right now you're a 6-5 football team. And guess what? That's just not good enough. That's not good enough for you, and it's certainly not going to be good enough for me."

Fat Chollie in 2009: "Charlie Weis says he can't envision a scenario where he would resign."
Yep, his words coupled with a loss to UConn pretty much sealed his fate.

Would an estimated $18 million buyout have anything to do with it? :D
Perhaps, but he would really miss the all-you-can-eat team buffets more than the money. :rolleyes:
 
From ESPN.com:
"Weis has told people in South Bend that he already has heard from roughly six NFL teams about becoming their offensive coordinator next season, sources told ESPN NFL Insider Adam Schefter."

There are 6 pro teams that need an offensive coordinator? That is a surprise! Who is going to fire one to get this lemon? Or maybe, just maybe, Chollie's delusions are running even more rampant than ever (i.e. he was going to go better than 10-2 this season, IIRC.)
 
From ESPN.com:
"Weis has told people in South Bend that he already has heard from roughly six NFL teams about becoming their offensive coordinator next season, sources told ESPN NFL Insider Adam Schefter."

There are 6 pro teams that need an offensive coordinator? That is a surprise! Who is going to fire one to get this lemon? Or maybe, just maybe, Chollie's delusions are running even more rampant than ever (i.e. he was going to go better than 10-2 this season, IIRC.)

in 4 years as New England's OC, Charlie was a part of 3 Super Bowl Championships. As an OC in the NFL, a "lemon" Charlie is not.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 0, Members: 0, Guests: 0)

Who Read This Thread (Total Members: 1)