D*'s DVR's are no TIVO. If you like TIVO, you probably won't like D*'s offerings. You can probably get used to them ,even maybe tolerate them eventually, but make no mistake, they are NO TIVO. Better? To some folks, yes. To others,like me, not on your life.
Doesn't really matter though, if you want D*'s HD and you want a DVR, you will get the non-TIVO.
My personal opinion? After trying the new DVR for 9 months, I left D*. It was totally underwhelming to me.

I have no use for VOD,media share, ESATA storage or anything like that. I wanted a rock solid HD-DVR to record and play back programs, with all the functions of a TIVO. The HR20 wasn't it, unfortuantely. Some folks have good luck with them, some don't.
Good luck with your decision. Just remember there is NO TRIAL PERIOD for D*, unless you live in a state that allows it. Once they install it, and you sign for it, it's YOURS for two years. Well, kinda. You still have to send it back should you cancel.

And pay the end of contract too.

Its a Win-Win. For directv anyway.
