The OP said he started with a 501, had it replaced with another 501, and is now running a 508.Now, I would say you have bad satellite tuner chip in the 508, it's well known issue.
Seems odd the same problem would plague him through all three PVRs.
501's were known for a bad tuner chip.
I've never seen nor heard of a 508 with a bad one - they changed to a new (pin-compatable) with the 508's and used it in the 510 as well.
Of course, with Echostar refurbs, I suppose anything is possible.
