I think I have a pretty good idea who the 5th cylon is, again assuming the other four are correct in their diagnosis of themselves.
Did anybody else happen to notice that Laura Roslin was in obvious extreme pain exactly when the power went off throughout the entire fleet? If she is a cylon, well I guess that changes everything? I still can't explain Kara showing up though.
Good point, I forgot about that! I don't think the 5th is Starbuck but there is something special about her indeed. I am still confused on the whole Watchtower thing and how it fits in and I'm bummed that we are going to have to wait for months and months to pick back up on this!