I've been reading Sat Guys for many years. Long enough to remember when Directv and Dish were referred to as "D" and "E". I have subscribed to both and am thinking about coming back to "D". A few questions please. I should know this one but when I first go to the FORUM section I see numbers for both "D" and "E". For "E" they are 73,200/1,048,137 and for "D" they are 32,766/38,422. I would expect "D" to have the higher number since they have more subscribers. It also seems to me that the "E" Forum is more informative in general. They have a Hopper Section yet "D" has no Genie section. In the past I have seen a Hopper review from Scott but don't recall seeing one from Scott on the Genie. I am also surprised to see the release of the Hopper 3 but no news on a upgrade to the Genie unless it's the HR54. Is something else coming? I do like the Auto Hop on the Hopper and wondered if it is a proprietary feature with "E". The last Genie I looked at used a guide that went out only 90 minutes compared to "E"s three hours. Three hours seems more logical since it encompasses all of the Prime Time coverage thus making recording selections easier. It probably sounds like I prefer the Hopper and I suppose I do but I'm going to switch because of PQ and cost, like many people are going. FYI, PTAT is also an awesome feature which I would love to see "D" adopt.