I've used both DiSEqC and 22kHz tone switches with a receiver, but have found that if I am using a satellite tuner card (a TBS model) with TVHeadend, the 22kHz tone switches just don't seem to work, at least not after a DiSEqC switch. I have not tried to use one by itself with the tuner card, it's always been after a DiSEqC, (tuner card <—> DiSEqC <—> 22kHz <—> LNB) but that always worked fine with a receiver rather than a tuner card. Also, with a 22kHz tone switch you can only switch between two sources, whereas you can buy four-port DiSEqC switches and switch between four sources (would be eight if the 22KHz tone switches would work like they do with a receiver). So, if all else were equal I'd pick a DiSEqC switch, but that's just a personal preference.What ever best fits your needs. At the dish or at the receiver. I have two systems and use both methods. But I don't use a DiSEqC switch for that, I use a 22khz tone switch to combine C and Ku. I put the Ku on the tone side and C-Band on the no tone. Then I can use a dual LOF setting that is offered by many receivers; 5150/10750. So both Ku and C for each sat in the list.