Looks like MLB is adding one more playoff team

S

SandraC

Thread Starter
On Vacation
Apr 10, 2008
7,302
0
NJ
Sounds like it will be a one game playoff between the top two wild cards. What do you guys think?


Sandra
 
M

Mr Tony

SatelliteGuys Pro
Supporting Founder
Nov 17, 2003
299
48
Mankato, MN
so we had one of the best last days of the season with both wild card games going to the wire and now Bud Lite is gonna be like youth baseball games where they dont keep score and "Everyone is a winner"

BAD MOVE
 
Neutron

Neutron

Founding Supporter
Supporting Founder
Nov 7, 2003
18,730
1,122
Texas
I don't agree with any changes he's announced today.
 
dangue

dangue

Pub Member / Supporter
Lifetime Supporter
Dec 29, 2007
4,887
1,226
SF Bay Area
I'm going to take a wait and see approach. I think the wildcats has worked out much better than most thought it would when first implemented. This has the potential to provide more meaningful games at the end of the season. And makes the difference between being a wild card and the division champ huge. Win division, guaranteed to get a five game series. Be a wildcard team and you have a one game playoff. Anything can happen in one game... Anything.

Sent from my iPhone using SatelliteGuys
 
M

Mr Tony

SatelliteGuys Pro
Supporting Founder
Nov 17, 2003
299
48
Mankato, MN
so what happens when the wild card winner (using current format) is say 5 or 6 games ahead of the "2nd" wildcard? Just dilutes it even more
 
Neutron

Neutron

Founding Supporter
Supporting Founder
Nov 7, 2003
18,730
1,122
Texas
In order to make this more fair (I still don't agree with any of this though), is he will have to add 2 more wild cards to each league. Seed it like the NBA, NHL, and NFL does with the 1st place team playing the 4th wild card, 2nd wild card plays 3rd wild card. Again I feel the current system works well now.
 
salsadancer7

salsadancer7

SatelliteGuys Master
Jun 1, 2004
28,020
183
South Florida
I'm going to take a wait and see approach. I think the wildcats has worked out much better than most thought it would when first implemented. This has the potential to provide more meaningful games at the end of the season. And makes the difference between being a wild card and the division champ huge. Win division, guaranteed to get a five game series. Be a wildcard team and you have a one game playoff. Anything can happen in one game... Anything.

Sent from my iPhone using SatelliteGuys

I too will have to agree with a wait an see approach.
 
S

SandraC

Thread Starter
On Vacation
Apr 10, 2008
7,302
0
NJ
so what happens when the wild card winner (using current format) is say 5 or 6 games ahead of the "2nd" wildcard? Just dilutes it even more

Well to be fair the same thing happens right now in baseball and all sports. No matter how many games you finish ahead of the other team, you still start the playoffs 0-0. This doesn't change that.


Sandra
 
S

SandraC

Thread Starter
On Vacation
Apr 10, 2008
7,302
0
NJ
Well I guess I'm in the minority, but I like it. This gives real incentive to win the division. Even though it may not be a good thing for my team...I still like it.


Sandra
 
cosmo_kramer

cosmo_kramer

Master of my Domain
Pub Member / Supporter
Oct 13, 2005
23,363
20,198
41.605N, -72.879W
My first thought is that it penalizes the first (current) WC team. A one-game playoff would require both teams to use their best available pitcher in that game, making him unavailable for the first few games of the next round.

I know the goal is just to win and get in, but it's kinda like the added teams and play-in games to March Madness. Fans of those teams may be riveted, but to everyone else, meh...
 
S

SandraC

Thread Starter
On Vacation
Apr 10, 2008
7,302
0
NJ
My first thought is that it penalizes the first (current) WC team. A one-game playoff would require both teams to use their best available pitcher in that game, making him unavailable for the first few games of the next round.

Actually, this is one of the exact reasons I like it. I look at this totally differently. It gives more advantage to the team that finishes first...as it should be.


Sandra
 
Jimbo

Jimbo

SatelliteGuys Master
Lifetime Supporter
Jul 14, 2005
64,695
4,691
NW Ohio - Buckeye Country
IF they're gonna add this addl. WC, it has to happen in Both leagues, so your adding 2 teams....
Ok, however, I DON'T like the 1 game playoff, they need to be a 3 game or it's not worth it.

Personally, I think it should stay the way it is.
 
BillD1984

BillD1984

SatelliteGuys Master
Apr 9, 2008
15,199
582
MA
My first thought is that it penalizes the first (current) WC team. A one-game playoff would require both teams to use their best available pitcher in that game, making him unavailable for the first few games of the next round.

I know the goal is just to win and get in, but it's kinda like the added teams and play-in games to March Madness. Fans of those teams may be riveted, but to everyone else, meh...


This!!
 
BillD1984

BillD1984

SatelliteGuys Master
Apr 9, 2008
15,199
582
MA
Actually, this is one of the exact reasons I like it. I look at this totally differently. It gives more advantage to the team that finishes first...as it should be.


Sandra

Fine, then have NO Wild Cards (and we all know that won't be happening).
 
dangue

dangue

Pub Member / Supporter
Lifetime Supporter
Dec 29, 2007
4,887
1,226
SF Bay Area
BillD1984 said:
Fine, then have NO Wild Cards (and we all know that won't be happening).

Sorry, but no wild cards is an awful idea. Case in point would be this year's world champions, the Cardinals wouldn't have even been playing October baseball if not for the wild card. Another case in point was the 1993 (I believe that was the year) Giants, won 100+ games but didn't make the playoff because Atlanta had one more win (I believe it was 103 and 104 wins respectively). That's an outright travesty.

Besides those examples, the wild card provides two added benefits. 1) more meaningful games later in the season (teams that are out of contention for the division are still fighting for a playoff birth) 2) rewards additional teams that may have great records but just happen to play in tougher divisions. (Is anyone else amused when a wild card team has a better record than a division winner?)

Sent from my iPhone using SatelliteGuys
 
Ramy

Ramy

The Star Wars Collector Podcast
Supporting Founder
Jan 27, 2004
30,897
512
Here
Even if they add 2 Wild card teams in each league then does one team get a bye the next round?
If they just add one then does the best team in each league get a bye?
 
S

SandraC

Thread Starter
On Vacation
Apr 10, 2008
7,302
0
NJ
Even if they add 2 Wild card teams in each league then does one team get a bye the next round?
If they just add one then does the best team in each league get a bye?

Ramy, my fault for not wording the title correctly. They are going to add one more wild card in each league. There will most likely be a one game playoff between the two wild card teams in each league, which will then leave four playoff teams in each league.


Sandra
 

Similar threads

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 0, Members: 0, Guests: 0)

Latest posts

Top