Stackable switches

comfortably_numb

Thread Starter
Dogs have owners, cats have staff
Pub Member / Supporter
Nov 30, 2011
9,345
9,943
Missouri/Kansas
I see some switches being sold and advertised as "stackable." Does that mean I could use 2 of the 4-port switches to make an 8-port switch?
 

Brct203

SatelliteGuys Pro
Dec 24, 2016
1,053
1,041
Connecticut
Thanks. What would be a practicle application for stacking?
well, you could consider having a 4-port switch near a dish, for example to switch between several LNBs on the same motorized dish (C, Ku, maybe Circular C), and then one cable, and then bring that cable to another switch which could also be fed by a few stationary dishes in another location (where it would not be so practical to have everything connected to just one switch).

In theory you can cascade a Diseqc 1.0 and a 1.1. But I have tried without success. I'm not sure if the problem was a limitation of my switches (a Pansat 1.1 and several no-brand 1.0), or a limitation of my receiver (Amiko miniHDre). If someone knows the answer, i'm interested :)
 

comfortably_numb

Thread Starter
Dogs have owners, cats have staff
Pub Member / Supporter
Nov 30, 2011
9,345
9,943
Missouri/Kansas
well, you could consider having a 4-port switch near a dish, for example to switch between several LNBs on the same motorized dish (C, Ku, maybe Circular C), and then one cable, and then bring that cable to another switch which could also be fed by a few stationary dishes in another location (where it would not be so practical to have everything connected to just one switch)
In this scenario, how does the receiver know which switch is which?
 
  • Like
Reactions: olliec420

Brct203

SatelliteGuys Pro
Dec 24, 2016
1,053
1,041
Connecticut
In this scenario, how does the receiver know which switch is which?
My understanding is that you could connect a Diseqc 1.1 to the receiver, and then several 1.0 switches to each input of the 1.1 switch. So in each combination, the path of the active LNB would go at most through one 1.0 switch and then the 1.1 switch. In the satellite configuration in the receiver, you typically have a selection for the 1.0 protocol and another line for the 1.1 protocol. (at least the Amiko does). But maybe i'm doing this wrong, since it did not work for me...
 

a33

SatelliteGuys Pro
Feb 4, 2015
436
304
netherlands europe
On diseqc switches, does this help? Dish Expansion: What is Committed/Uncommitted?

Every diseqc switch 'knows' exactly to what command(s) it will respond, and will not respond to other commands. So in your receiver you have to match the diseqc commands to the switch-ports at which your LNBs are connected.

About the use of the word 'stackable', I have no idea to what qualities of the switch they refer. As written in the link: every diseqc switch can be used serially (and so be 'stacked' in a cascade), and they pass through power and signal only to the chosen port.

With Ecoda 22kHz switches, that is different: power and 22kHz is passed on to both ports always, and only satellite signal is switched.

So to what special quality the refer I don't know.
But maybe they use 'stackable' for every switch, just as they advertise for 'HD-LNBs, suitable for 4K' (as if a normal LNB wouldn't suffice...)

Greetz,
A33
 
Last edited:

comfortably_numb

Thread Starter
Dogs have owners, cats have staff
Pub Member / Supporter
Nov 30, 2011
9,345
9,943
Missouri/Kansas
Every diseqc switch 'knows' exactly to what command(s) it will respond, and will not respond to other commands. So in your receiver you have to match the diseqc commands to the switch-ports at which your LNBs are connected.
Makes sense, as "Port A, B, C, D" would be the only option for a Diseqc 1.1 4x1 switch. But if you stack another 4x1 switch into the mix, there doesn't appear to be a way to distinguish between the two
 

KE4EST

SatelliteGuys Is My Second Home
Staff member
HERE TO HELP YOU!
Lifetime Supporter
Aug 9, 2004
25,175
5,509
EM75xb
Have you read this thread? Switch setups simplified

On the Amiko if you run into a 8X1 switch and then a 4X1...
In the settings for the satellite you want. Under DiSEqC 1.1 choose which port of the 8X1, the 4X1 is attached to. Then in 1.0 choose which port of the 4X1 the LNBF is attached to. :)
 

a33

SatelliteGuys Pro
Feb 4, 2015
436
304
netherlands europe
Makes sense, as "Port A, B, C, D" would be the only option for a Diseqc 1.1 4x1 switch. But if you stack another 4x1 switch into the mix, there doesn't appear to be a way to distinguish between the two
Have you read the link I gave? A diseqc 1.0 switch cannot react to a diseqc 1.1 command, and vice versa.

A diseqc 1.1 command goes something like this:
"Hey, to all switches, listen up! Is there a diseqc 1.1 switch there? If so, do you have a port 14 to switch to? Then do so. If not, ignore this command."

So there is unique distinguishment for all the 64 switch ports that can be reached by a 16/1 diseqc 1.1 switch and 16 4/1 diseqc 1.0 switches; or the other way round: one 4/1 diseqc 1.0 switch and 4 16/1 diseqc 1.1 switches.

A33
 

Brct203

SatelliteGuys Pro
Dec 24, 2016
1,053
1,041
Connecticut
Have you read this thread? Switch setups simplified

On the Amiko if you run into a 8X1 switch and then a 4X1...
In the settings for the satellite you want. Under DiSEqC 1.1 choose which port of the 8X1, the 4X1 is attached to. Then in 1.0 choose which port of the 4X1 the LNBF is attached to. :)
yeah that's what I did... No luck switching the Diseqc 1.0 switch (located between the LNB and the Diseqc 1.1 switch)
 

KE4EST

SatelliteGuys Is My Second Home
Staff member
HERE TO HELP YOU!
Lifetime Supporter
Aug 9, 2004
25,175
5,509
EM75xb
Interesting. But to be honest, I have not experimented with it in a long time.
 

primestar31

SatelliteGuys Master
Lifetime Supporter
Mar 15, 2005
8,760
5,165
Beta Omicron Delta III
yeah that's what I did... No luck switching the Diseqc 1.0 switch (located between the LNB and the Diseqc 1.1 switch)
Have you checked the Diseqc 1.0 switch all alone, to make sure it didn't fry? NEVER hook/unhook POWERED coax from a Diseqc switch, otherwise you are taking a big chance you'll blow it out.
 

Brct203

SatelliteGuys Pro
Dec 24, 2016
1,053
1,041
Connecticut
Have you checked the Diseqc 1.0 switch all alone, to make sure it didn't fry? NEVER hook/unhook POWERED coax from a Diseqc switch, otherwise you are taking a big chance you'll blow it out.
yep, it's definitely good

I remember seeing a project about making a Diseqc "reader" using an arduino or similar microcontroller. Maybe I should try making one so that I can analyze the signals at each step.
 

a33

SatelliteGuys Pro
Feb 4, 2015
436
304
netherlands europe
Testing the switching functionality of diseqc switches can easily be done by testing the 'output voltage' on the input ports. There should be 13 or 18 volts on the reached port, the not-reached ports have 0 volt.

Can be done with a multimeter, but also with a satbeeper (light is on only when voltages is there), or with a diode+resistor (see e.g. Diseqc switch testen voor ie het dak opgaat)

Greetz,
A33
 

a33

SatelliteGuys Pro
Feb 4, 2015
436
304
netherlands europe
yep, it's definitely good
So, leaving the 1.1 switch out, the 1.0 switch works OK?
And vice versa, leaving the 1.0 switch out, the 1.1 switch works OK?

What 1.1 switch do you have? There was an EMP switch that repeated commands, that caused problems with 1.0 switches.

What diseqc command setup do you have in your receiver?

Greetz,
A33
 

Brct203

SatelliteGuys Pro
Dec 24, 2016
1,053
1,041
Connecticut
So, leaving the 1.1 switch out, the 1.0 switch works OK?
And vice versa, leaving the 1.0 switch out, the 1.1 switch works OK?

What 1.1 switch do you have? There was an EMP switch that repeated commands, that caused problems with 1.0 switches.

What diseqc command setup do you have in your receiver?

Greetz,
A33
exactly, all the switches work fine individually.

so for example, if i have the LNB on port 2 of the 1.0 switch, with the output of the 1.0 connected to port 5 of the 1.1 switch, in the receiver I would select :
Diseqc 1.0 : port 2/4
Diseqc 1.1 : port 5/8

The 1.1 switch is the Pansat from Casey's store: Hypermegasat.com, FTA Switch etc

the 1.0 switches are "Premium XHD" and "ViewSat"
 

a33

SatelliteGuys Pro
Feb 4, 2015
436
304
netherlands europe
Diseqc 1.1 : port 5/8
I would expect 5/16, but if you have 5/8 in your menu, that is OK also. :)

Do you have options like setting command order or diseqc repeat in your receiver? Have you tried those?

Another thing that can happen, is that a newly reached 1.0 switch has a relatively high starting current, causing the 1.1 switch to 'reset' and go to port 1 again.
That is because in the cheaper switches, they sometimes leave out a capacitor at the switching IC, it seems, that would normally equalize voltage fluctuations.
This effect (the switching to port 1 again) should be detectable, I would say, but I've never come across this myself.

If the problem lies in 22kHz commands not reaching the 1.0 switch, due to hardware insufficiencies, I wouldn't know how to test that further...

greetz,
A33
 

Brct203

SatelliteGuys Pro
Dec 24, 2016
1,053
1,041
Connecticut
I would expect 5/16, but if you have 5/8 in your menu, that is OK also. :)

Do you have options like setting command order or diseqc repeat in your receiver? Have you tried those?

Another thing that can happen, is that a newly reached 1.0 switch has a relatively high starting current, causing the 1.1 switch to 'reset' and go to port 1 again.
That is because in the cheaper switches, they sometimes leave out a capacitor at the switching IC, it seems, that would normally equalize voltage fluctuations.
This effect (the switching to port 1 again) should be detectable, I would say, but I've never come across this myself.

If the problem lies in 22kHz commands not reaching the 1.0 switch, due to hardware insufficiencies, I wouldn't know how to test that further...

greetz,
A33
No I don't think the receiver has those options

I could possibly try to plug in my oscilloscope at various points and try doing a recording and seeing if I can analyze the 22kHz data.

I do know that the 22 kHz tone used to switch universal LNBFs is passing thru all the switches, since i'm able to use those LNBFs are working fine when using one switch at a time.
 

DVB-S2

SatelliteGuys Family
Oct 6, 2013
73
44
so for example, if i have the LNB on port 2 of the 1.0 switch, with the output of the 1.0 connected to port 5 of the 1.1 switch, in the receiver I would select :
Diseqc 1.0 : port 2/4
Diseqc 1.1 : port 5/8
Would you not have to ensure the Diseqc 1.1 command is sent first to 'open' port 5 before the Diseqc 1.0 command is sent, otherwise there's no way for the 1.0 command to reach its destination?

I have successfully cascaded comitted and uncommited switches and vice-versa, using both a MicroHD receiver and a DVB card.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)

Top